Christmas in July: Griffith’s Park Controversy Starts Early

The Entrance to the Festival of Lights, 2007 

The Griffith Park’s annual Festival of Lights is supposed to be one of the highlights of the holiday season for thousands of Angelenos.  The park is festively lit up by the Department of Public Works in an effort to make the park visible from the moon an outpouring of Holiday Spirit.

What’s also becoming a bit of a tradition is the battle over the city’s illegal exclusion of cyclists from the event.  With the exception of a "cyclists night" that occurs in mid-November before Thanksgiving, bike riders are banned from the event in violation of state law that clearly states that municipalities cannot ban bikes from roads except for freeways.  Naturally, bike activists find this ban an affront to their rights and engage in a yearly battle with the city.  Last year, even the Times joined bike blogs such as Illuminate LA in decrying the festival’s ban.

This year cyclists are off to an early start.  On June 9th, a group of cyclists, the Sierra Club, local
Neighborhood Councils, homeowner associations and equestrians attended a public meeting on the festival to ask the DWP to lift the ban on bikes.  Some went so far as to suggest a festival wide ban on cars.  Thus, instead of 100,000 cars idling through stop and go traffic; pedestrians, cyclists and
even equestrians could enjoy the nation’s largest urban park and its unique light festival.  DWP hasn’t announced either a lifting of the bike ban or imposing a car ban.

The cyclists efforts don’t end with bureaucratic committee meetings, Illuminate LA has also written to Councilman Tom LaBonge, asking him to help lift the ban because it is against state law.  The full text of their letter is available after the jump.

July 1, 2008
The Honorable Tom LaBonge
City Council District 4
200 North Main Street
Los Angeles, CA

Dear Councilmember LaBonge:

The 2008 Griffith Park Holiday Light Festival is upon us and discussions are already underway
between the DWP and the community on the elements of the Festival. However, before any
decisions can be made as to the form and function of the Festival, it is imperative that the DWP
and the Festival cease to violate State law by excluding cyclists from the same streets that are
open to the motoring public.

I contend that the current ban on cycling in the LADWP Festival of Lights at Griffith Park is a
violation of California Vehicle Code because the city does not have the express authority (per CVC
21) to regulate bicycling on non-freeway roads. An outline of this position is attached.
Suggestions by DWP reps that the ban on cyclists is for safety purposes are simply absurd and
irrelevant. Festival auto traffic is typically so congested that riding the Festival by bike is safer that
the access streets used by a cyclist to get the Festival.

Regardless of the DWP’s well-intended perception of safety issues, keep in mind that cyclists not
only ride the 6500 miles of LA streets but also ride over 1000 miles of Freeway & Highway
throughout the State of California. This access is guaranteed and protected by State Law.

Ultimately, it is State Law that trumps any desire to restrict cyclists to a “special” night. I ask you to
remedy this situation by intervening on our behalf and by acting to prevent the DWP and its
Festival Partners from violating the cycling community’s right to enjoy access to our streets.

I do not intend to discount your commitment to the Holiday Light Festival nor to our community but
instead simply urge you to support cycling as a legal and viable transportation choice on the
streets of Los Angeles, all of them!

Image: beastandbean/Flickr 

  • Tom LaBonge has been unresponsive and the fight continues…

  • On no less than Christmas Eve of last year, coming back from Burbank I was making my way around the south end of the zoo parking lot at 4:30 p.m. — still daylight and some 30 minutes before the vile nightly Festival of Lights’ ban on bikes commences. A Park & Rec Dept. employee about a football field away saw me and started waving his arms and yelling that I couldn’t pass. I shook my head and told him it wasn’t 5 p.m. yet but this idiot actually took a position in my path in some sort of ridiculous attempt to stop me. Fortunately I was able to evade his blocking maneuver and he responded by getting on his radio perhaps in an attempt to bring reinforcements. I yelled over my shoulder again that it wasn’t five fucking o’clock before advising him where he could stick his walkie talkie. At the other end of the festival course apparently his cohorts didn’t share his stupidity or enthusiasm and wisely made no attempt to apprehend me.

    Sorry, didn’t mean to go on for so long. I was one of the cyclists at that meeting last month. Stephen Box spoke very eloquently about the positive reverberative impact the DWP could make in taking the lead and flipping the ban from bikes to cars, but it was a notion immediately shot down by the dismissive and at-times combative DWP representative present.

  • will is my id

  • I’m Will’s id!

  • If this is illegal, then can cyclists sue the City of L.A. to see this come to pass?

  • Hmmm! Interesting question Mr. Ubray.

    The City of Los Angeles has no legal authority to restrict the access of cyclists as long as the streets are open to motorists. (CVC 21)

    Further, Councilmember LaBonge has taken an oath to uphold the law and to support and defend the Constitution.

    I would suggest that a cyclist would be in position to sue if they were denied legal access to the Festival of Lights. Further, I would contend that Councilmember LaBonge would have violated his oath of office if he were to be a party to this civil rights violation.

    No entity, not even the City of Los Angeles, is above the law.

    See you on the Streets!


Griffith Park Lights Festival Closed to Cyclists in 2008

Cyclists hoping to open the Griffith Park Holiday Lights Festival to bikes were disappointed on Wednesday when new access was provided for equestrians and canines but bikes were banned except for the special "bike night" on November 28th.  Cyclists have insisted that not allowing them to bike the light festival is a violation of state […]

The Week in Livable Streets Events

Right before the holiday break, it seems the number of events for activists wane as the number of events celebrating the season increase.  This week’s calendar features only one government meeting of note, the Annual Holiday of Rights, and a chance to do something about bike parking in Pico-Union (along with the parties…) Tuesday – […]

City Council “Passes” Cyclists Bill of Rights

Stephen Box Discusses Cyclists Rights at the "Festival of Rights" It’s been an eventful 24 hours for those cyclists engaged in the battle for better recognition of cyclists rights.  Last night was the "Festival of Rights," the third annual protest of the ban on bicycles during the Griffith Park Festival of Lights except on special […]

Good Sam’s Blesses the Bikes

A multi-faith approach to bike blessings This morning Good Samaritan Hospital held one of the most popular events of Bike to Work Week, the Blessing of the Bicycles.  This marks the sixth year that Good Sam’s has held this event to celebrate cycling, mourn the cyclists lost since last year’s blessing and bring together some […]

Why the Festival of Rights Matters

Cyclists gather at the Festival of Lights for this year’s Festival of Rights protest ride. Photo: Soap Box Some see it as a niche ride for activists.  Some see it as Stephen Box’s attempt to get on television and continue his feud with Councilman Tom LaBonge.  Still others as a ride that engenders mire bad […]

Festival of Lights Meeting Tonight

Speaking of Tom LaBonge…earlier in the month Streetsblog reported on the efforts to overturn the city’s ban on bicycles during the Festival of Lights in Griffith Park. Tonight, activists will have another opportunity to urge the DWP to follow the state law prohibiting banning of bicycles from a public space at a meeting about the […]