Skip to Content
Streetsblog Los Angeles home
Streetsblog Los Angeles home
Log In
Parking

Donald Shoup: Planners Are Versed in Parking Politics, Not Policy

le_bleu.jpg
Un-Shoupian parking policy on display on Brooklyn's Fourth Avenue

The Toronto Star gave parking policy maven Donald Shoup some major play earlier this week, running a profile of the UCLA professor excerpted from journalist Tim Falconer's new book, "Drive." In the piece, we learn why Shoup believes planners are apt to make bad judgments when it comes to the optimum supply of off-street parking:

...planning departments always insist that developers include aminimum number of parking spots. Shoup doesn't have much respect forthe ability of urban planners to determine how many spots arenecessary. Since planners don't learn anything about parking in school,they learn it on the job, but because parking is so political -- NIMBYneighbours constantly squawk at the thought of anyone parking on theirstreet -- what they really learn is the politics of parking.

Hardly surprising, perhaps, but certainly applicable to New York, where parking minimums have facilitated pedestrian-hostile development, as on Brooklyn's Fourth Avenue. It also raises the question: Even if the city were to muster the political will to adopt Shoupian pricing for on-street parking (following the lead of San Francisco and Washington), would it have the fortitude to address another big part of the equation by reforming zoning regs that require parking in certain residential buildings?

A story in today's Times about the suspension of alternate-side parking rules in Park Slope shows the warped sense of entitlement such measures would run up against:

“Parking is such a joke in this neighborhood that no matter what theydo, it won’t make a difference,” said Buddy Ferriola, from the deliPollio on Fifth Avenue. “You got 20,000 cars and 2,000 parking spaces.”

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog Los Angeles

Supervisor Hahn and Councilmember Ricks-Oddie: “Pull the Plug” on Metro/Caltrans 91 Freeway Expansion in Long Beach

Supervisor Janice Hahn: “I think it’s pretty clear that we’re going to need to pull the plug" on planned mile-long $174 million 91 Freeway project

July 23, 2024

L.A. Street Vendors Celebrate Removal of No-Vending Restrictions in Huge Win Against City

The victory is the product of a decade-plus-long battle to legalize sidewalk vending on our city streets

July 23, 2024

This Week In Livable Streets

East L.A. Food Bicycle Tour #3, Metro/Caltrans 91 freeway expansion, Metro board meeting, C Line delays, Metro East Valley light rail, and the Citywide Housing Incentive Program Ordinance

July 22, 2024
See all posts