Judge Slams, Stalls Pico-Olympic Plan

Maybe it’s not such a "done-deal" after all.

Mayor Villaraigosa and Councilman Jack Weiss, the two elected proponents of speeding up traffic on Pico and Olympic Boulevards at the expense of local businesses and non-motorized travel, were dealt a setback yesterday when a Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge ruled that the city needs to study the impacts of the project before moving forward.  To read the ruling, click here.

The Pico-Olympic project has caused heated debate since Villaraigosa announced it last fall. Controversy over the project wasn’t just spurred by businesses being scared by a loss of parking at rush hours, but also by a "press conference over policy" approach to lawmaking. Residents were furious that they didn’t hear about the plan until watching it on the news or reading it in the newspaper after a press conference. As more details on the plan were released, such as the traffic counts were completed on a Jewish Holiday, the community grew more incensed and pleaded with their Councilmembers to kill the project.

Attempts by the City Council to discuss the proposal were effectively tabled when Villaraigosa declared that the plan was moving forward and he didn’t need the council’s approval. In a perceived slap to Councilmember Bill Rosendahl, the most recent revision included the entirety of the roads in Rosendahl’s district while cutting out the part of the plan in Councilmember Herb Wesson’s district.

Villaraigosa declared that the plan would go into effect the first weekend in March. It was then delayed until the end of March after local business groups filed suit. Most recently, the plan was set to go into motion "later this week."

City Watch reports that the lack of a public process wasn’t lost on the judge.

"The undisputed evidence is that City Council Transportation Committee meetings on the proposed activity were abruptly suspended and the City’s Department of Transportation was instructed to implement "phase one" of the plan by the Mayor."

"In this instance," Judge Torribio went on, "where the city has not prepared any environmental document."

So what’s next for the Pico-Olympic Plan? The Times reports that the Mayor’s Office is still debating whether or not to appeal the decision, but in the meantime will begin an environmental review that could take 6 months to a year to complete.

A third option to get the plan moving again would be if the City Council declared that the project had no significant impact. After the Mayor’s snub last winter, it’s hard to see that taking place. Maybe steam rolling all concerns in a typical "design and defend" campaign wasn’t the best idea after all.

  • Radical Transportation Engineer

    I am quite surprised to see that the city council can just declare that there is no significant impact. Is that without a study at all? That’s awesome. I didn’t know the city council studies traffic engineering and environmental impacts before taking the oath of office. Nice system.

    Without sarcasm now…I am happy to see that a judge has taken a stand and is not just bowing down to the Mayor. This Mayor seems to think that as long as he speaks well and looks good, the content of his policy doesn’t matter. I’m very surprised he’s not an Obama supporter.

  • This whole one-way plan is such a typical L.A. thing.

    Concerns about the damage this plan will have on the interests of local residents are ignored or supressed. THe plan is all about moving more cars, faster, at the expense of everything else in the city.

    Is it any wonder that L.A. loses so much money to retail business areas in other cities? Our roads are designed to pipe as much money as possible outside of the city!

    Slower car speeds = better business in our neighborhoods.


City/Locals Clash on Pico-Olympic Plan

Could there be a better illustration of the divide between the DOT and the community? As I sat and watched angry/scared locals from along the Pico-Olympic corridors testify against the Mayor’s Pico-Olympic plan, I suddenly felt bad for LADOT Transportation Engineer Ken Husting. Basically, it shouldn’t have been this way. The residents and business owners […]

Community Slams Mayor, Weiss on Pico/Olympic Plan

"The medium is the message" is a well known saying among Public Relations theorists. In the story we’re about to discuss, the medium used to send the message was the traditional media. By choosing that medium, the unintended message that the community received was "up yours." When Mayor Villaraigosa and Councilman Jack Weiss held a […]