Metro Board Looks to Improve Bus Service, Including Expanding All-Door Boarding

L.A.'s transit workhorse: the  Metro bus.  Photo via Wikimedia
L.A.'s transit workhorse: the Metro bus. Photo via Wikimedia

Yesterday, the Metro board approved three items that set the stage for bus service improvements.

Metro is getting close to rolling out its multi-year bus service reorganization effort – called the NextGen Bus Study. This month the board approved NextGen’s “Regional Service Concept” which is full of high-level platitudes like “provide high-quality mobility options” and “the bus system is easy to understand and use” and “customers are satisfied.” There are hints at what changes are being contemplated: “shorter route lengths,” “coordination” with municipal bus service, “standardize frequencies”, “subarea transit hubs” (ie: a system less centered on downtown L.A.), improved “stop spacing,” and “transit supportive infrastructure.”

These over-broad statements were accompanied by an over-long staff report featuring a 63-page summary of study outreach, data evaluating existing line ridership, and a ranking of existing lines based on a complex Route Performance Index. All this appears to leading to big, positive, needed changes… but the angels and devils will be in the details. And those remain elusive.

Just when will the riding public see NextGen changes on the ground?

Metro had published a two-year schedule, showing a draft plan that would be shared internally starting in September, then approved by the board in early 2020, then implemented in three phases starting April 2020… but that schedule has now been scrubbed from the agency website. Generally not a good sign.

Metro NextGen schedule as distributed and posted last week
Metro NextGen schedule as distributed and posted last week
Metro NextGen implementation schedule shows a three phase rollout starting April 2020
Metro NextGen implementation schedule (now removed from the agency website) shows a three phase rollout starting April 2020

It was replaced with the below detail-free six-month version, which shows a draft plan release in December, and board approval and implementation at some unspecified time in 2020.

Metro's revised NextGen schedule
Metro’s revised NextGen schedule

NextGen will improve L.A. bus transit. As with nearly any major changes to pretty much anything anywhere, it is likely to draw its share of criticism. Hopefully, all the data work and outreach will pay off.

Several boardmembers do not appear to be waiting for NextGen to substantially transform Metro bus service.

The board approved two motions for bus improvements that are ostensibly in conjunction with NextGen, but, to some extent, allow needed improvements to perhaps jump the queue – ie: proceed outside the confines of NextGen.

All-door boarding is a key improvement that Streetsblog has covered several times. Several U.S. transit agencies have system-wide all-door boarding, which speeds up buses and even saves money. So far, Metro has only implemented all-door boarding on Vermont and Wilshire Rapid buses and on the Silver Line BRT. Transit advocates have encouraged Metro to expand the program.

Yesterday, the board approved a  motion from County Supervisor Janice Hahn to accelerate all-door boarding and other bus improvements. The motion was co-sponsored by boardmembers Hilda Solis, Eric Garcetti, Mike Bonin, and Paul Krekorian.

In addition to all-door boarding, the Hahn motion calls for accelerating:

  • installation of durable vinyl seats
  • better TAP, network, and schedule integration between Metro and Municipal Bus Operators
  • more real-time arrival electronic displays
  • incentivizing more bus shelters

The motion directs Metro to report back on these improvements at the November/December 2019 board meeting.

The board also approved a Bonin motion on improving bus speeds. That motion was co-sponsored by boardmembers Garcetti, Solis, Krekorian, and Robert Garcia.

The motion directs Metro to:

  • “Develop a list of priority bus-supportive infrastructure projects needed to support the NextGen bus service plan, with an emphasis on near-term improvements that can be implemented concurrently with each phase of NextGen”
  • convene a “NextGen Bus Speed Engineering Working Group” with Metro and the Los Angeles City Department of Transportation (LADOT), to meet monthly and report back to the Metro board operations committee quarterly
  • coordinate with local jurisdictions and municipal operators to improve bus speeds “where bus delay hot spots exist”


Metro Board Wrap: Votes for Cleaner Buses, Then Less Buses

Earlier today, the Metro Board of Directors approved a motion cutting 305,000 bus service hours in a surprisingly close 7-6 vote. In addition to the expected opposition from bus riders, concerns about the cuts were raised about what “replacement” buses will be created for areas where rapid buses will be cut and the total impact […]

Metro Proposes More Cuts to Bus System

Earlier this week, Metro announced another set of proposed cuts to its bus system.  Following so soon on the cuts from just last month, Metro CEO Art Leahy took to The Source to defend the changes.  Oddly, rather than defend the good work being done by the bus division at Metro and push for the […]

What Corridors Could Be Best for BRT? Metro’s Study Progresses

Back at the August 4, 2011 Metro Board meeting Los Angeles Mayor (and Metro Board member) Antonio Villariagiosa authored a motion that directed Metro undertake among other bus service improvements initiatives a Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) study ” … with local jurisdictions to identify, analyze and recommend a minimum of five corridors in the County […]

LADOT Questions Metro’s Bus Cuts

Last month, the Metro Board passed a resolution requiring staff to prepare a memo outlining total service cuts from 2007 and expected cuts for 2008 and 2009. Board Members wanted to put the proposed bus service changes for this June into a larger context to better understand the impact on local economies and Metro’s ridership. […]

Transit Coalition Blasts Service Cuts

Bart Reed of the Transit Coalition takes off the kid gloves in this week’s LA City Beat accusing the Mayor of being the instigator for over 200,000 hours of cuts to Metro’s bus system and Board Member Yvonne Burke of being hysterical and wrong about the need for turnstiles. The interview can be divided into […]

Metro in 2010: More Rail, BRT and Highways. Less Bus Service

Photo: Marco Siguenza/Flickr Even with Measure R, not even Metro is immune to bus service cuts. At 2:30 this afternoon, Metro will hold its public hearing on the staff-proposed 2010 budget.  The budget will also be heard at next week’s Full Board Meeting before being voted on.  The budget doesn’t contain a lot of surprises, […]