Metro Board Discusses Bike-Share; Report and Transit-Bike Transfers Both Due in September

Metro Bike Share docks in downtown L.A. Photo: Joe Linton/Streetsblog L.A.
Metro Bike Share docks in downtown L.A. Photo: Joe Linton/Streetsblog L.A.
This article supported by Los Angeles Bicycle Attorney as part of a general sponsorship package. All opinions in the article are that of the author, and do not necessarily reflect those of LABA. Click on the ad for more information.

At yesterday’s Metro board meeting, a couple of announcements and some boardmember discussion offered some hints regarding the future of Metro Bike Share. Further decisions on the fledgling system will be the subject of a staff report due back at the board’s September meeting.

As part of her board chair remarks yesterday, County Supervisor Sheila Kuehl announced that Metro Bike Share walk-up usage is up 50 percent since the agency reduced prices in early July. Kuehl also announced that “bike-transit transfers” would be available this September: “With TAP card integration, transit users will be able to ride our bikes after their transit ride without any extra payment.”

More of the board’s positions on bike-share became clearer when a narrow bike-share staff report back grew into a broader discussion. Metro staff were responding to a request from boardmember and Glendale City Councilmember Ara Najarian for Metro to push legislatively to have bike-share trips count as transit transportation. While bike-share is eligible for some governmental funding programs, including many California greenhouse gas reduction programs, bike-share is not uniformly eligible for Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) funds. Metro staff recommended that Metro support Oregon congressmember Earl Blumenauer’s bill H.R. 3305 which would clarify that bike-share is eligible for FHWA funding.

The brief discussion on the funding triggered a broader bike-share discussion among the Metro board:

  • Long Beach Mayor Robert Garcia, whose city operates Long Beach Bike Share a smart-bike CycleHop system, decried Metro’s over-reliance on funding its smart-dock system. Correction 7/30: Long Beach bike-share system was initially operated by CycleHop, but the city took over operations in August 2017.
  • Duarte Councilmember John Fasana, citing ofo private dockless bike-share’s withdrawing from the U.S. market, questioned whether Metro should be directly operating bike-share especially in such a dynamic market.
  • County Supervisor Kathryn Barger expressed her disappointment that Metro was consistently “one step behind” on bike-share, citing Pasadena’s decision to withdraw.
  • L.A. City Councilmember Mike Bonin, a major champion of bike-share, expressed that Metro shouldn’t lock into any one bike-share technology, and stressed the importance of TAP integration and inter-operability among multiple systems.
  • County Supervisor Hilda Solis stated that bike-share needed to advance equity by serving commuters, not just “leisure” use. She also pushed for Metro to work with the county bring bike-share to the East L.A. portion of her supervisorial district.
  • Chair Kuehl outlined her vision that Metro riders would utilize multiple systems, where “at every station something would be available but it’s not necessarily ours.” She also proposed that Metro look into TAP integration with e-scooters.

Metro staff emphasized that the Metro Bike Share program did make recent changes, and that staff are due to report back to the board in September. A performance report and a full discussion on the program’s future will take place then.

Metro bike-share staff are in an unenviable position. Their systems compete with private sector mobility devices – dockless bike-share, e-bike share, e-scooters – that are subsidized by venture capital. These private companies have the ability to more-or-less turn on a dime responding to situations on the ground. Metro Bike Share is nowhere near that nimble. It must be responsive to directions of thirteen Metro boardmembers who meet ten times each year. Proposed changes must be vetted with agency and board staff, approved by the board, then rolled out; the process can easily take a few months. Metro is working to expand the system, and to convert the Venice fleet from smart-dock to smart-bike, but these upgrades will still be underway in September.

Metro’s September discussion will likely be based on only a couple months’ of utilization data under the new pricing structure. Though the system is working well in Venice and adequately in central Los Angeles, this may not suffice for the approval of boardmembers who represent other parts of the county.

Metro Bike Share certainly has some flaws. Among these are an inability to serve the mobility needs of low-income people, and a lack of utility in that it covers only a fairly limited geographical area. But Metro’s freeway projects, which cost several orders of magnitude more than Metro’s bike-share investment, also fail to serve the needs of low-income Angelenos. These highway expansions generate greater pollution burdens for low-income communities – a drawback that bike-share does not share. Metro’s rail system has been criticized for its limited geographic reach, even after 25 years of growth.

To make Metro Bike Share effective, the board and staff will need to keep on top of the dynamic market. Bike-share ridership growth will take time. Investment and expansion need to be strategic. As Garcia, Bonin, and Kuehl have asserted, a single rigid one-size-fits-all approach is unlikely to succeed, especially in a quickly changing mobility environment. Over time, though, bike-share has the potential to serve as a key ingredient in a rich mix of mobility options open to all Angelenos.


County Wide Bike Share? Metro Committee Says “Yes, We Can”

Will Los Angeles County have an integrated bike share system in the next five years?  Metro is taking the first steps to become a coordinator for bike share efforts already underway so that L.A. County could have one integrated bike share program instead of many local bike share systems. Earlier today, Metro’s Planning and Programming […]

Bike Share Demonstration

Come, See, & Ride 3 vendors will be presenting their bikes: B-Cycle Bike Nation Bixi Wednesday, January 18, 2012 Between the Hours of 10:00 am and 2:00 pm Metro Headquarters, One Gateway Plaza, Los Angeles, CA 90012 Downtown Union Station Patsaouras Transit Plaza For Information regarding this event, contact Lynne Goldsmith (213) 922-3068 Metro bike […]

Lessons from NYC: Key to Bike Share is Walkability

(This is the second in a series of lessons from this car-free Angeleno who found himself in NYC for a year. Read the introductory installment here.) There’s a plannerspeak term: “first mile / last mile.” It generally refers to how to get folks to transit stops from actual destinations including home, work, stores, restaurants, and […]

Three Years Later: Is L.A. Ready for Bike Share

In September of 2008, Los Angeles was beginning to move towards creating a bike share system for Los Angeles.  It was a hot topic at the time after then City-Council Transportation Committee Chair and now Comptroller/Mayoral Candidate Wendy Greuel championed the idea after experiencing a successful temporary bike share program at the Democratic National Convention in Denver. […]

Five Key Tips For Metro Regarding Safe Bus-Bike Interactions

Early last week, Michael MacDonald posted his helmet-camera video showing a Metro bus driver veering rightward into his path, then braking. The incident occurred on Adams Boulevard near Hauser. When MacDonald confronted the driver, he responds dismissively and closes the bus window. The video bounced around the bike corner of cyberspace. It was picked up […]