NYC’s Plaza Program, An Open Space Model for L.A.?

(We’re kicking off a new series where transportation professionals write about some of the best practices in their city and how they could work in L.A.  Who better to start with than our favorite Occidental College Board Member? The NYC Plaza Program is a popular topic on our sister-site in New York.  – DN)

New York is the city that never seats.

With more than eight million residents and millions more commuters and visitors sharing just over 300 square miles, New Yorkers have long tried to squeeze everything they can out of every day and every inch of the city, but there’s just not enough places to sit and enjoy it all.

Plans for a plaza at Fulton Street and Marcy Avenue, in the first phase of the plaza program. Image: NYC DOT

While New York’s landmark buildings, parks and cultural institutions get a lot of attention, there’s less consideration given to the city’s most important real estate: the streets and sidewalks themselves, which make up 80 percent of the city’s public space.

With another one million people expected to move to New York over the next 20 years, every inch of this shared space will have to count. Our streets must be designed to be safer for everyone and, critically, they must be designed to invite people to walk outside and linger—to stop and take in everything the city has to offer.

Whenever we lay down traffic cones for a plaza project in New York, and long before the benches are installed, pedestrians immediately move in and take up the most New York of rituals: They sit down, even right on the street.
Los Angeles has 6,500 miles of streets—just as many miles as New York, and just as many opportunities to think about how its streets are being used. But just as most Angelinos aren’t lucky enough to live walking distance of Venice Beach, not everyone in New York is lucky enough to live near Central Park.

Mayor Bloomberg’s PlaNYC blueprint for a more sustainable New York called for ensuring that all New Yorkers live within a 10-minute walk of quality open space.

To reach that goal, we created the NYC Plaza Program, partnering with communities to transform underused slices of streets and sidewalks into welcoming, vibrant neighborhood plazas.

DOT accepts applications for plazas to be used as greenmarkets, performance spaces, or as a place simply to sit, relax and meet neighbors. The applications come from interested community organizations that demonstrate broad support in the neighborhood and which can prove they can fund, clean and maintain the space once it’s open.

These plans can create landscaped plazas where today there is a zebra-striped sidewalk lane; a place to enjoy a cup of coffee in what is an unneeded turn lane; or a spot to read a book in the crook of a century-old street where a couple hundred square feet are no longer needed to move traffic.

Reclaiming public spaces has already proven a huge success here, when Broadway at Times and Herald squares were converted to pedestrian plazas. In one fell swoop, this project improved safety, traffic flow and air quality while providing a welcoming space for visitors, residents and workers to sit and enjoy the Crossroads of the World. Business is also booming, with major new retailers flocking to Times Square opening and with retail rents there outpacing the rest of the city, all amid the economic downturn.

Ensuring we get the most out of our streets in the future means looking at how we’re designing them today. Los Angeles is taking a significant step in that direction with the development of the Model Streets Manual, establishing guidelines for how streets can be designed for everyone who uses them.

Not every plaza can bring every benefit in every case. But each plaza can help create a more community in our neighborhoods by giving residents a place worth walking to—and a place to sit and enjoy it.

  • amanda

    I nominate those right turn lanes at Virgil and Santa Monica for this sort of treatment.

  • Mike

    When traveling, I always notice the lack of greenery LA has compared to other World Class cities.  Adding parks like they did in downtown recently would make the city way more inviting to not only visitors, but to people living in the actual neighborhoods.

  • Imagine if we did this on Santa Monica Blvd instead of turning it into a mini freeway.

  • PlebisPower

    Love the idea and the implementation. NYC in some ways is so very different than when I was raised there.  But isn’t Manhattan is a city of centralities and convergences so ready to recapture for public? The outer boroughs and Los Angeles, on the other hand, seem comprised mostly of peripheries and interstices hard to imagine as plazas. For those relict spaces in the City of Angeles, where would the homeless move to if we recolonized them?  

  • JSK is my hero. We are obviously not New York, but Los Angeles could definitely use more public space wherever it can be accommodated.

  • Lois Arkin

    The NYC Plaza Program sounds similar to the program that Barcelona started after the end of the Franco dictatorship.  They similarly reached out to neighborhoods to have them design and maintain neighborhood plazas. On Sundays, most plazas there have community events–art shows, performances, etc.–and you can’t walk more than 10 or 15 minutes without coming to a neighborhood plaza.  What a treat.  And in a week of walking that city a few years ago, I never saw an ill maintained plaza.  What a fabulous idea to attempt such a democratic idea in NYC.  And why not LA?  We have way too many unnecessarily wide streets and intersections.  But, since we don’t have a Janette Sadik-Khan, this could take forever through conventional channels.  So, let’s just do it!  A little paint and urbanite.  A few orange vests.  Midnight work.   A few  successful guerrilla attempts should get our city politicians and bureaucrats moving quickly on this. 


A Review of Streetfight by Janette Sadik-Khan and Seth Solomonow

Janette Sadik-Khan’s new book Streetfight comes out next Tuesday March 8. Sadik-Khan will be in L.A. speaking and signing books on March 16 at the Hammer Museum and March 17 at Gensler in downtown Los Angeles. Congratulations to Erik Griswold who won Streetfight during SBLA’s pledge drive last week, and to Luke Klipp who won Gabe […]

Sadik-Khan Packs the House, Then Brings It Down

Thanks to Clarence Eckerson for this Streetfilms Shortie.  Sadik-Khan will be speaking again at the start of the StreetSummit this Saturday Last night, the L.A. StreetSummit kicked off with a rousing keynote address and slide show by the groundbreaking New York City DOT Commissioner Janette Sadik-Kahn.  Three levels of Occidental College students, bike advocates from […]