Chicago Pays the Price for Parking Privatization

It appears Chicago politicians who privatized city parking meter
operations traded short-term political gain for long-term fiscal pain.

faillong.jpgPhoto: Best Recession Ever

Chicago may have left as much as $974 million on the table under the terms of last year’s agreement with Morgan Stanley. A June report from the city inspector general [PDF]
blasted the deal for being rushed, secretive and vastly too expensive
for taxpayers. The report’s revelations incensed motorists already antagonized by a ragged roll-out of meter rate hikes.

All
in all, it wasn’t the money for nothing bargain the City Council seemed
to think it was back in December when Morgan Stanley handed over a
check for $1.157 billion. This manna from Wall Street plugged the
city’s gaping budget hole and allowed the council to avoid painful tax
hikes and service cuts. It also enticed lawmakers in Los Angeles and
Philadelphia, where officials were considering their own parking
privatization deals.

In return for the upfront cash, Chicago
leased its 36,000 parking meters for the next 75 years to the
Morgan-led consortium, and granted it the authority to double and
triple meter rates. By 2013 downtown meters are slated to double to $6
per hour; neighborhood meter rates are to double to $2 per hour.

The
deal was pushed hard by Mayor Richard Daley. The core of his
privatization argument was that Chicago lacked the political will to
raise meter rates and that desperate fiscal times demanded unlocking
the value of public parking. He noted that city meters were only
generating about $20 million a year, and because of neighborhood
resistance, meter prices hadn’t gone up in 20 years. His conclusion was
that Chicago had to outsource the political will to raise meter rates.

However,
the inspector general’s report concludes that, "If Chicago were to keep
control of the parking-meter system and operate it under the same terms
as the private company, the system would be worth approximately $2.13
billion (in present dollars)," or $974 million more than the city
received. Ironically, another cost of Chicago parking privatization was
that it
quashed a number of neighborhood-supported parking improvement
districts, in which higher meter fees were to be invested in local
pedestrian, bicycle and transit improvements.

While
public-private partnerships can be appealing because they require
motorists to pay more of the actual cost of driving, are these deals
really the only way to overcome political resistance to higher motoring
fees?

  • The ultimate revenge would be to make damned sure that long before that lease runs out, nobody is driving in Chicago… since it has so many wonderful pedestrian and bikeways!

  • Marcotico

    If I were a politician, I would use this as a threat! Let us raise your parking rates or we’ll privatize them!

    Muaah- hahahahhaha

  • Zane, don’t forget the L.

  • This all reminds me of the movie “Cool Hand Luke”, where Paul Newman destroys parking meters, and then eats a great deal of eggs.

    This also makes me think of Mayor Bilandic losing his election in ’79 after some poor snow removal planning. Chicagoans will put up with a lot, but they get upset when you mess with their streets.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Cities Learn From Chicago Parking Meter Debacle. Did Goldsmith?

|
When Chicago Mayor Richard Daley announced that he was striking a deal to privatize his city’s 36,000 parking meters, it was a golden opportunity for transportation reform. If all went well, the deal could have cleared a political path for higher peak-hour meter rates, curbing double-parking and congestion-causing cruising. But Chicago managed to completely bungle […]

Lessons from Chicago: What Could Happen to Parking in L.A.

|
Thus far, the discussion on how to, and whether to move forward with a plan to privatize the city’s metered street parking has focused on what impact a similar plan has had in Chicago.  The final deal between the Windy City and Morgan Stanley netted Chicago $1.16 billion up front, for turning over parking revenue, […]

Chicago Outsources Parking Reform to Morgan Stanley

|
The Chicago City Council has approved by a vote of 40-5 a deal to privatize the city’s 36,000 metered parking spots for the next 75 years, trading meter revenues for an upfront payment of $1.15 billion. Under the agreement with Morgan Stanley Infrastructure, meter rates will rise substantially and some meters will operate overnight and […]

Will City Look, or Just Leap at Plan to Lease Lots?

|
Later today, behind closed doors, the Los Angeles City Council will meet to debate and discuss whether to put out to bid a plan to lease all of the city controlled parking lots throughout the city for fifty years.  The debate over whether the city should proceed has been almost completely centered around whether or […]