Streetsblog Editor Kept Out of Metro Meeting Due to Bike Tools

"You can't bring these tools into the building" - the sheriff holding my bike tools. All photos by Joe Linton/Streetsblog L.A.
"You can't bring these tools into the building" - the sheriff holding my bike tools. All photos by Joe Linton/Streetsblog L.A.
This article supported by Los Angeles Bicycle Attorney. Click on the bar for more information.
This article supported by Los Angeles Bicycle Attorney as part of a general sponsorship package. All opinions in the article are that of the author, and do not necessarily reflect those of LABA. Click on the ad for more information.

I was going to post an article today about Metro’s East San Fernando Valley Transit Corridor Project.

But I had trouble getting into this morning’s public hearing.

This morning I rode the Red Line subway and the Orange Line BRT, then bicycled three miles to the Zev Yaroslavsky Family Support Center at the corner of Van Nuys Boulevard and Saticoy Street in Van Nuys. The Yaroslavsky center is part of the county’s Department of Public Social Services (DPSS); it’s a place where low-income folks go to access public services, including food stamps and Medi-Cal.

I locked my bike up at the bike racks in front of the building. I walked up and put my backpack and bike bag onto the conveyor belt to send them through the metal detector.

I bike for transportation. I carry a pump, spare tube, and tools for minor repairs.

As a reporter, I have submitted my belongings for inspection thousands of times to attend meetings at Metro headquarters, City Halls, the County Hall of Administration, and other government buildings. Prior to 9/11, I carried a bike multi-tool that included a knife blade, but as public buildings tightened security, I replaced it with a multi-tool that does not include anything sharp. These days, I attend meetings at Metro headquarters or L.A. City Hall nearly every week and I have no problem with my current set of bike tools. Sometimes guards want to see my tools, and once they see there’s nothing sharp, they let me in.

Once in a blue moon, there is a guard who won’t let me and my tools pass. This last happened about a decade ago at the LADWP headquarters, and I was able to ask to see a supervisor, who took a look at the tools and let me in.

SecurityatYaroslavskyCenter
Security this morning at the Zev Yaroslavsky Family Services Center

This morning, there were two security workers and an L.A. County Sheriffs Department officer working the door at the Yaroslavsky center. The guards and sheriff said that I couldn’t bring in any tools.

I asked if I could leave the tools with them. They said I could leave them in a trash can and retrieve them on way out.

I asked to see their policy. It was posted and had a prohibition against any tools more than three inches long.

Wrenches and multi-tool that I bike with daily
Wrenches and multi-tool that I bike with daily

The sheriffs officer objected to a Phillips-head screwdriver, that is part of a three-inch-long bike multi-tool that’s mostly Allen wrenches. The officer kept picking up my multi-tool, opening the two-inch Phillips-head screwdriver and making a jabbing motion – as if to convince me it was a weapon.

This is how the sheriff officer gestured with my small Phillips-head screwdriver
This is how the sheriff officer gestured with my small Phillips-head screwdriver
The Phillips-head screwdriver is 2-inches long as part of a 3-inch long multi-tool
The Phillips-head screwdriver is 2-inches long as part of a 3-inch long multi-tool

I asked to speak with a supervisor. I talked with an LASD representative on the phone, then with the manager of the building. The manager suggested I move my bike to the back of the building and leave my tools on it there. He asserted that bringing bike tools — which he called “a sharp object more than three inches long” — into the building was “dangerous to other people.”

Twice I was told to put the tools “in your car.”

Finally, I threw my tools into the trash and went into the meeting.

The meeting offered plenty of anti-bike sentiment: (These meetings continue tonight and this week; cyclists, pedestrians and transit riders should attend and speak.)

  • Metro’s project manager was generally good in describing the beneficial aspects of the planned transit project to an audience that expressed some hostility and skepticism (mostly due to the need for property acquisition for a rail yard). He sounded a wrong note, to my ears, in describing Metro’s inclusion of first/last mile improvements, which he characterized as to “improve aesthetics,” then went on to list possible first/last mile features including wheelchair access curb-cuts. Is that really just aesthetics? Please, Metro, the vast majority of your riders arrive by foot and by bike. Please don’t devalue our trips by calling our facilities “aesthetic improvements” or amenities.
  • A representative from the Valley Industry and Commerce Association (VICA) stated the organization’s position that “bike lanes are not appropriate for Van Nuys Boulevard,” and that the project instead needs to preserve parking there. A speaker who mentioned he was from the Panorama City Neighborhood Council stated that bicycles on the “high traffic corridor” was “just dumb” and urged Metro to provide a corresponding bike facility somewhere else that was quieter.

I went back to the security checkpoint just in time to see one of the security officers pouring coffee into the trash can where my tools were. I fished out my wet tools, took off on my bike, and headed home.

When I am cycling, drivers cut me off and honk at me. When I park my bike, racks are often substandard and often installed badly. I attend public meetings, where I am told that I don’t deserve safety, where I am told that I don’t pay taxes for transportation, that “normal people” drive, and that “every lane is a bike lane” so I shouldn’t push for anything safe for cyclists. On social media, I see a similar stream of insults.

Yaroslavsky center, according to one website, has a 1,326 space parking structure. At at typical Los Angeles construction estimate of $25,000 per above ground structured parking space, this represents a $33 million investment for drivers.

I expressed frustration at the security guards. I wonder how a working class immigrant cyclist – who often ride on less reliable bikes, and carry less compact tools to keep those bikes working – would have fared in an encounter where they got mad at a Sheriff’s deputy.

I get around by bike and transit because I want a healthier, safer city for me, for my family, and for all Angelenos. I want a great, healthy, safe city for my daughter to grow up in. At a time when record-breaking climate change-charged hurricanes are causing massive devastation, and when state climate change goals call for reducing greenhouse gases from the transportation sector, this morning’s encounter with more official bike hostility feels discouraging. It dampens my hopes for the future. If L.A. is ever going to get to be a sustainable equitable livable city,  cycling – including the tools and infrastructure people need to keep rolling – is going to need to affirmed as legitimate and acceptable.

  • So you were forced to change from Red Line to Orange Line at North Hollywood/Zev Yaroslavsky Station?

    http://www.latimes.com/opinion/opinion-la/la-ol-the-stop-the-political-naming-madness-20140919-story.html

  • I’ve run into the same problem at SBCTA (formerly SANBAG). I’ve just resorted to driving.

  • Alethea Nelson

    Yeah, I have shown up for jury duty on the bus with a small wrench on my keychain and I had to hide it in a planter. When I asked if I could leave it with them, they told me to leave it in my car, even when I said “I do not have a car, I came here by bus.” “Well you can leave it in your car, that’s it.” This was in Riverside. I lock my bike bag to the seat-post and hope for the best.

  • Simon

    Sorry to it. Thank you for your work.

  • jennix

    Thanks Joe. FWIW, multitools seem to be as dangerous as switchblades when you wear a badge and star in “Security Theatre”. I’ve come to expect it… even border crossings will confiscate the damn things now.

  • Joe Commuter

    This right here spells out why our efforts can feel so hopeless. Brand new public building and over a thousand parking spaces and only a token bike rack. Sorry this happened to you, Joe. Little museum-like lockers is a great idea. Or a holding area for “dangerous weapons.” Maybe a lost-and-found? Some quality protected bike parking would be nice too.

  • Lorenzo Mutia

    “A speaker who mentioned he was from the Panorama City Neighborhood Council stated that bicycles on the ‘high traffic corridor’ was ‘just dumb’ and urged Metro to provide a corresponding bike facility somewhere else that was quieter.”

    It’s disappointing to hear that coming from someone who is supposed to represent a largely working class neighborhood. If Van Nuys Blvd is heavily trafficked why wouldn’t you put bike facilities? The nearest north-south streets that are contiguous (because a lot have dead-ended at the railroad) are too far to be of any use anyway.

  • Nathan Bousfield

    No pens allowed in public buildings, they might be used as stabbing weapons.

  • mk4524

    Contract guards working at minimum pay. You get what you pay for. At least the guards eat well

  • The thing is, there’s no consideration by Metro when booking a facility like this that it might have security screening and that the screening might not have the same standards as those encountered at Metro HQ. Then there is the county and the low-bid, who cares, why-didn’t-you-drive-in-a-car-here-you-loser attitudes that, while it impacted Joe and his bike tools, probably also bans things like syringes, epi-pens and “large” bags of one sort while allowing larger “bags” of another style. Death of common sense at the Los Angeles County level (you can’t have a storage box LASD?) but someone at Metro made the choice to hold the meeting here. Shame on them for not vetting.

  • User_1

    I always wanted to make some belt buckle that is also a useful multi-tool for bikes. My bet is that anyone with a serious belt buckle would take you with your “sharp object”.

  • D Man

    You know you suffer from white privilege when the oppression you face is not being allowed to take your multi-tool into a community meeting.

  • D Man

    Correct, bike lanes should not be placed on high traffic streets as it increases the risk of bike/car accidents and, assuming there is a road diet, creates unnecessary traffic which increases emissions and global warming. Bike corridors should be placed on side streets with less car traffic, which is safer for cyclists.

  • michael macdonald

    You’re literally spending your apparently limitless disposable time trolling a reporter in the comment section of a website to highlight the white privilege of others?

  • Haighter

    Thanks for the writeup, Joe. It’s discouraging, but keep it up. I’ve also had my pedal wrench confiscated at an airport (7″ limit by TSA), and when parked in front of a supermarket had my saddle bag containing my multi-tool and spare tube stolen. Unfortunately my solution so far is to not carry tools while doing short around-town trips, and assume I can use the bus system or walk to get back home.

  • @D Man – What is it that you hope to accomplish with sneering?

    I know a lot of white people, myself included, who have faced a range of official abuses, from this kind of petty authoritarianism through brutal arrest, simply for riding bicycles. Each such abuse is a teachable moment; a privileged person who would otherwise have no exposure to our criminal justice system will never view it in the same way again. We become more likely to sympathize with others being brutalized by the same injustice system.

    Each volley of sneering teaches nothing of value (apart from some insight into the psychology of the sneerer).

  • disqdude

    How is this white privilege? I’m sure minorities, who constitute a huge percentage of the Los Angeles population, would face the same hassles by rent-a-cops.

  • neroden

    It’s time to fire every last one of the cops and border guards and other rent-a-thugs.

    What are they good for, anyway? Clearly not for solving crimes.

  • neroden

    In my small town, anything they don’t allow through into the courthouse will be stored in cubbyholes behind the guard and can be retrieved when you leave. Anything short of a firearm can be stored in these cubbyholes.

    What the hell is wrong with LA?

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Streetfilms Praises Orange Line BRT and Bike Path

|
While in town last month, Streetfilms took its second look at Los Angeles’ Orange Line as a model for BRT’s around the country.  In his summary of the above Streetfilm, Clarence Eckerson doesn’t hold back his praise for the Orange Line calling it "one of the best Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) systems in the U.S" […]

Streetsblog Interview: Ayla Stern

|
Bicycle Advisory Committee Member.  Bike Working Group volunteer.  Midnight Rida.  Co-Founder of the Valley Bikery.  When it comes to advocacy Ayla Stern does it all.  Recently, she’s been one of the leaders of the battle to preserve the Wilbur Avenue Road Diet and Bike Lane re-striping that has won praise from cyclists and residents but […]

LADOT Announces Public Hearings on Bike Master Plan!

|
The City of Los Angeles is holding four community meetings around the city this February and March as part of its effort to update the Bicycle Master Plan. Everyone is invited to attend and will be given a chance to tell the city how you feel about our bike facilities. The meeting time/locations are: Central/South […]