City Council Approves Controversial Westside Transit Oriented Development

Image via Martin Expo Town Center

Yesterday, the Los Angeles City Council approved the largest transit-oriented development near a new Expo Line Station in Los Angeles’ Westside. The development, located at the 4.7 acre site owned by the Martin Automotive group sits at corner of Olympic Boulevard and Bundy Drive. The project is mixed use, with significant housing, 150,000 feet of neighborhood-serving retail, genuine transit-integrating features, and shared public spaces.

“Martin Expo Town Center includes a higher percentage of affordable housing than any project of this kind in the history of Los Angeles, it features neighborhood-serving retail and an exceptional pedestrian plaza, it will create thousands of permanent jobs, and it offers needed additional parking for the nearby Expo/Bundy station that will help connect more people with mass transit,” writes L.A. City Councilmember Mike Bonin who represents the district where the project is located.

The development will have over 516 housing units, 20 percent of which will be affordable housing and five percent of which will go to house the recently homeless. The original proposal did not have an affordable housing component.

Image via The Coalition to Preserve LA
Image via The Coalition to Preserve LA

Naturally, the project is not universally popular. The Coalition to Preserve L.A. mailed a full-color glossy brochure to Westside residents this summer encouraging them to fight the project. The coalition was working with a who’s-who of Westside residents’ and homeowners groups including West of Westwood Homeowners Association, West L.A.-Sawtelle Neighborhood Council, Brentwood Homeowners Association and Westwood South of Santa Monica Blvd. Homeowners Association. 

Many of the features bragged about in Bonin’s press materials were slammed in the Coalition’s piece. From the coalition’s website.

As noted in the Coalition to Preserve L.A. mailer, Martin Expo Town Center will jam 516 residential units and at least 150,000 square feet of office space on the Martin Cadillac site, and will create 7,151 more car trips daily and 16 new gridlocked intersections. It also seeks a half-dozen on- and off-site liquor licenses and permits for live entertainment.

Taken on my iphone, on the way to a pre-schooler's birthday party, in August.
Taken on my iphone, on the way to a pre-schooler’s birthday party, in August.

The project does have a multi-modal transportation component, which Bonin feels mitigates any increased traffic the project will create. The parking plans include 100 car spaces reserved for Expo Line users and over 600 short- and long-term bicycle parking spaces. Some of the spaces will be reserved for a car share program. Others will be reserved for e-vehicle charging.

In addition, the developer will work with Metro to provide transit passes for residents at a discount paid for by the development.

Last, Bonin points out that they negotiated for the developer to pay for other improvements to protect the neighborhood from increased car traffic. The developer will pay for a raised median on Bundy to prevent illegal left turns and cut through traffic near the development. It has also committed to fund $250,000 for the installation of a traffic signal at the Olympic entrance if the neighborhood wants it.

But these accommodations are not enough for many Westside residents’ groups. According to the Coalition to Preserve L.A. website, these groups are angry that a “spot-zoning” agreement was ratified by the City Council without a hearing by the Planning and Land Use (PLUM) Committee.

The PLUM Committee was scheduled to hear the proposal last week, but, according to Committee Chair and Councilmember Jose Huizar a filing error forced them to scrap the planned hearing. Rather than waiting for two weeks until the next hearing, the full City Council held the hearing earlier this week on Tuesday.

The filing screw-up is giving more rhetorical ammunition for the Coalition to Preserve L.A., which is not just fighting local transit-oriented development, but also pushing the Neighborhood Integrity Initiative, which would put a two year moratorium on any spot-zoning that is on the ballot in March of 2017.

“City Hall’s handling of the mega-project, which needs the Council’s approval, only underscores the need to reform L.A.’s broken and rigged planning and land-use system that consistently favors deep-pocketed, politically connected developers,” writes former L.A. Weekly reporter Patrick McDonald on the Coalition’s website.

If the Coalition sees the project as a defeat for the community and the process, Bonin sees the project completely differently.

“Hundreds of neighbors showed up to more than 150 individual and community meetings that were held about this project over the past four years to provide feedback and suggestions, which were incorporated into the project. Thanks to their work and support, and thanks to the project developer’s willingness to significantly change the proposal to incorporate our feedback, this is the right project for this important location.”



Gold Line Foothill Extension Photo Tour: Transit Oriented Development (TOD)

In this fourth installment of the Foothill Gold Line Extension photo tour series, we explore planned Transit Oriented Developments (TOD) around some of the line’s future stations. Recently, Streetsblog’s Damien Newton and Aviv Kleinman joined a behind-the-scenes tour of the newest Gold Line Extension phase under construction in the San Gabriel Valley. We joined Albert Ho, head […]

The Lorenzo Project in South L.A. Is Controversial, But Is it T.O.D.?

Last week, at a packed meeting of the City of Los Angeles Planning Commission, the Commission punted on a proposed $250-million residential development known as the Lorenzo.  The developer, Geoffery Palmer of Palmer Construction, is known for his other Italian-themed apartment developments Medici, Visconti, Orsini and Piero. He’s also known for successfully challenging a local […]

Metro Did the Right Thing By Not Over-Parking Expo Line Phase 2

Metro’s Expo Line Phase 2 opens this Friday. Though there is a lot of excitement and praise for the line, the Expo extension from Culver City to Downtown Santa Monica has also received some criticism. Note that Expo Phase 1 weathered its own criticism, and exceeded expectations. Some critics are suggesting the line could be “doomed” […]

Coalition Grows in Opposition to Proposed No-Growth Ballot Initiative

Communities United for Jobs and Housing, a growing coalition of affordable housing developers, community leaders, climate activists, transit advocates, and elected officials, has formed to oppose efforts by no-growth activists to pass a November ballot measure that would severely curtail, among other things, the city’s ability to address Los Angeles’ worsening housing shortage. Nearly 40 […]