Mayor Villaraigosa Calls Critical Mass Attack “Disturbing”

6_8_10_villar.jpgThe Mayor’s not as comfortable talking bikes as he is transit, so he used the LACBC Blog to get out his message.   Photo from last month’s Measure R, 30/10 Rally.

Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa responded to an open letter from the Los Angeles County Bicycle Coalition concerning the incident from May’s Critical Mass ride where the LAPD was caught on tape kicking at cyclists and attacking a different rider recording the incident.  Instead of his press office,  Villaraigosa uses the LACBC’s blog to make his official statement on the attack, video and the LAPD’s follow-up.

There’s nothing ground-breaking in the response, the three sentences can be summed up as,"Cyclists have the right to the road and fair policing.  It’s good that Beck is trying to make things better for cyclists.  The video is disturbing, but I trust the LAPD to make this right."  You can read the full statement at the LACBC Blog.

I’ve already heard some complaints that Villaraigosa’s response wasn’t stronger or didn’t announce a policy change of some sort in addressing the assault.  But when you compare the Mayor’s statement to that of another big city mayor in a similar situation, Villaraigosa’s is actually a step forward when it comes to recognizing the rights of cyclists on a Critical Mass ride.

In 2008, progressive transportation hero and New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg found himself in a similar situation after an NYP officer knocked a cyclist off his bike during a Critical Mass ride.  You can watch video of that incident here.  As was the case in L.A., the mayor responded after video of the assault made the rounds on the evening news. 2008 actually shows that L.A.’s Mayor is taking a stronger stand.  Unlike Villaraigosa, it didn’t take Bloomberg ten days to respond.  However, Villaraigosa’s, actually took the initiative on his own, instead of waiting for a reporter to quiz him, and he responded directly to cyclists on the LACBC’s own blog.

Bloomberg’s response was also more vague than Villaraigosa’s.  The Big Apple mayor wouldn’t condemn the actions of then-officer Patrick Pogan when it was obvious to anyone watching the video of his assault on cyclist Christopher Long, even though charges against Long were still pending.

"It looked to me to be totally over the top and inappropriate, but
the police commissioner is going to or is in the process of doing an
investigation. I don’t want to prejudice any investigation," said

Personally, I’d much rather have a Mayor who first announces that he believes cyclists have the right to the road before condemning the incident as disturbing, than listen to Bloomberg’s equivocation.  Villaraigosa’s stand is another sign, joining his office’s defense of a set-aside for cyclists and pedestrians in the city’s Measure R funds.  In a lot of ways New York is miles ahead of Los Angeles in the race to be have the most sustainable transportation system, but our elected leaders seem to be recognizing that the old ways are not working.  These might be baby steps, but as the saying goes, every journey begins with one step.

  • Kevin

    You report: “However, Villaraigosa’s, actually took the initiative on his own, instead of waiting for a reporter to quiz him, and he responded directly to cyclists on the LACBC’s own blog.” Unfortunately, he really didn’t take any initiative. He waited several days and only responded after LACBC sent him an open letter (leaving him very little choice but to respond). I fear that actions (or lack thereof) speak louder than words. I hope I am wrong.

  • Kevin,

    There’s a lot of “open letters” to the Mayor about biking that I’ve seen. This is the first time he wrote back. Am I giving him too much credit for responding directly to cyclists instead of running for a tv camera?

    Second, I think you all are not giving him enough credit for clearly taking the cyclists’ side. Would you have been surprised if his statement was something like;

    “While I don’t condone the actions taken by these officers, they were in a difficult situation being surrounded by so many cyclists who were clearly breaking the law. I expect the police commission and internal affairs investigates this issue fully.”

    Because that’s what I expected. Maybe I just suffer from lowered expectations.

  • Kevin

    As I wrote before, I hope I am wrong about the Mayor’s actions. And it’s probably not so much that you suffer from lowered expectations as it is me suffering from being an incurable cynical cyclist (hey, the cynical cyclist… sounds like a blog).

  • ay… sad that we celebrate such a tepid non-committal response. We can only hope that this is the PR response and that other pushing is going on behind the scene.

    Mayor Villaraigosa – you can lead the city into a 21st century vision for safe, healthy streets! Please show leadership on this! Please commit your city to respecting bicyclists!

  • Seriously, does this letter bear the indelible hallmark of a letter written by Mayor V? Or is it more likely that this is a statement issued by his office? To say that he personally wrote the letter is like saying that he personally writes his tweets – it is well known that his tweets are written by a staffer. It’s pretty clear that this statement was written by a staffer as well.

    It’s worth noting that the statement can be read both ways. Cyclists will see it as a condemnation of LAPD’s actions, but officers of LAPD will read it as equally condemning cyclist action. Classic statement and not actually a commitment.

  • Just Me

    Your mayor Villaraigosa needs to take a PUBLIC SPEAKING CLASS, this man stumbles through his whole speech. His favorite word is uh, uh, uh, and then he goes blank.


What to Expect at Friday’s Critical Mass

Believe it or not, this was done with the officer’s consent. Photo: Digable Soul/Flickr Critical Mass has gone mainstream.  Following last month’s "Critical Mass Attack," where an officer was caught on tape kicking at cyclists’ bikes before the cameraman was tackled to the ground, it seems you can’t go anywhere without reading or discussing Critical […]

Cyclist Who Filmed Critical Mass Attack Files Claim Against LAPD

Friday afternoon at the Petroleum Building in Downtown Los Angeles, Manuel Gallegos and his attorney Hermez Moreno announced the filing of a legal claim against the City of Los Angeles and the LAPD for assault, battery, false arrest, false imprisonment, malicious prosecution, and intentional affliction of emotional distress.  The full press release is available at […]

Helmets Ready! Mayor Hosts First Bike Summit

Former Mayor Richard Riordan presents training wheels to the wounded Mayor. For more pics from the conference, visist Gary Rides Bikes’ Flickr Page Despite the Monday 9am hour and the picture perfect weather, a standing-room only crowd assembled in the Metro Board Room for city of Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa’s first Bike Summit.  Alongside Mayor Villaraigosa […]