What To Do After an Accident When the Police Fail to Respond?

(Farid Yaghoubtil is an attorney with the Downtown L.A. Law Group. Following last week’s story on the LAPD’s failure to cite a driver in a crash involving a cyclist, Yaghoubtil asked if he could write a piece on what cyclists can do to get the best legal results after a crash…not that it would have helped in last week’s incident. – DN)

The moments immediately following a traffic accident can be confusing, leaving the victims in a state of bewilderment and shock.  In the most serious accidents, the injured parties are hopefully quickly transferred to a local hospital where they are given immediate medical care.  Dealing with the aftermath of the accident becomes an ancillary concern, and the focus justifiably shifts to the well-being of the accident’s participants.  However, what about situations where an ER visit is not necessarily needed? 

The first step in any traffic accident situation would be to contact local police department and have them write up a report regarding the accident.  While many accident victims are tempted to forego this crucial step, it is essential to resist this urge.

Many times, the at-fault party accepts fault immediately following the accident, only to change their story once they speak to their insurance provider or when they are in a courtroom setting.  Without a police report that confirms the true story, innocent victims are frequently left with only their word in defending their position.

Further complicating the issue is the fact that time and again the police department, especially in busy metropolitan areas such as Los Angeles, will simply refuse to come out to the scene of the accident.  In fact, Ted Rogers of Biking in L.A. recently reported  on the story of Melanie Freeland, which is one of the most egregious examples of police inactivity we have ever seen.

Whether this is due to police indifference, a general lack of resources, or simple police bureaucracy, the fact remains that accident victims are sometimes  left dealing with the repercussions without the benefit of police involvement.  This can be especially crippling for victims that are left with thousands of dollars worth of medical and property damage bills.

Therefore, in light of Mr. Roger’s report, the following is a list of additional measures that should be taken after an accident that could protect your rights following an accident.

1. Witnesses can be your best friends – Other than a police report, independent witnesses are the most credible pieces of evidence in proving your innocence.  Look out for anybody who may have witnessed the accident, politely ask for their information and if they would be willing to provide a statement in the future.

2. Take pictures – Sometimes, the only way to demonstrate how an accident actually occurred is to reconstruct the scene of the crash.  Take pictures of all the motor vehicles involved, the scene, the road, skid marks, injuries, or any other picture that might help in proving your case.

3.  Look at nearby businesses – Many business have surveillance that not only monitor the store, but also the surrounding areas.  Unfortunately, these videos are usually disposed of, sometimes after only one day.  Make sure you contact these establishments to see if they have video surveillance that can be beneficial to your cause.  If so, ask them to preserve the evidence.

4.  Get a statement from the at fault party – With the advent of the Smartphone, almost everyone has a video camera at their disposal.  Ask the at-fault party to make a statement.  Individuals are far more likely to be honest immediately after the crash rather than a few days or hours later, when the initial shock has subsided.

* Although this article focuses primarily on how to act immediately following an accident, I wanted to add one final note on uninsured/underinsured (UM/UIM) motorist coverage.  UM/UIM coverage protects innocent accident victims in situations where the at-fault party does not have sufficient insurance coverage, or fails carry any coverage to pay for all the damages.  It also protects individuals in hit-and-run accidents, where the perpetrator is never found.  Most people have never heard of UM/UIM coverage, but with more and more people driving without insurance, it can often be the single most important aspect of an insurance policy.  UM/UIM coverage not only protects victims of car accidents, but any type of motor vehicle crash such as bicycle, pedestrian and motorcycle accidents.

  • KillMoto

    … and for god’s sake, don’t refer to it an “accident” until there’s a fair and impartial investigation that rules out negligence or other non-accidental causality. Call it an incident, a wreck, or something that does not imply the hurt was caused by an unavoidable, inevitable act of god.

  • Scrolf

    So, if you don’t own a car and therefore don’t have a motor vehicle insurance policy it probably isn’t likely that you have UM/UIM insurance and in the case of a hit-and-run would be left footing the bill for someone else hitting you. Is this correct? Do most insurance companies carry a product for cyclists to protect themselves?

  • Joshua Cohen

    You can also get bicycle insurance through Spoke and some other companies, although Progressive offers a non-operator’s UM policy with $100,000 for the injured cyclist. This is the best option for cyclists I’ve found. It costs about $100 a month for a 30-year old woman, which pales in comparison to the potential costs of your medical treatment if you’re hit by a car on your bike. You may also want to look into long-term care insurance (which pays for your non-medical care if you’re disabled) and disability insurance (which pays for your living expenses as well as those of your family).

  • Okay, so what do you do when you’re the victim of an intentional hit and run, and you manage to convince the police to begrudgingly take a report, and then a few weeks later they mail you a form letter with the name and address of your assailant with no explanation for what, if anything, happens next? That’s what happened to me. Are they going to charge him, or am I supposed to sue the guy myself now, or what? I don’t have any physical damage, so maybe the LAPD just doesn’t think it’s a big deal?

  • Mycelium


Glendale Traffic Cops Botch Report on Fatal Bike Crash

Site of the crash. Not the business district. Image: Google Street View When we last checked in with the Glendale Police Department, we were entertained by the sight of an officer in a giant bunny costume being used in a traffic sting to catch motorists that ignored pedestrian crossing.  The story wasn’t just encouraging, officers […]

Language Is Important

This terrible headline via the Huffington Post It’s been a common theme when Streetsblog covers crashes to note the soft bias of the writing and headlines in more traditional news sources.  This bias nearly always deflect guilt away from the people who cause the crashes. It amazes me when I watch coverage of a tragedy […]

Penetrating the Myth of L.A.’s Safety

At City Watch and his personal blog Soap Box, Stephen Box punched an SUV sized hole in the Mayor and Police Chief Charlie Beck’s claim that the City of Los Angeles has become the “second safest big city in America, after New York.”  Box’s contention is that because the city assumes that most traffic crashes […]

Edit My Questionnaire for the City Attorney Candidates

Photo: Los Angeles Times I’ve been promising for awhile to write out questionnaires for the remaining candidates for City Attorney.  Here are a couple of questions I would like to put to paper, but since the whole point of blogs is "two-way communication" how about all of you play editor and review my questions and […]

Bike Sharing Coming to USC and City Passes Rough Timeline for Anti-Harassment Ordinance. Speed Limit Increases Delayed.

The City Council met today and discussed two cycling related issues.  The first was the ongoing discussion of whether or not the city should have a bike sharing program.  Second, the Council debated how to create an ordinance that would better protect cyclists from harassment. As predicted, Councilman Rosendahl moved to "re-open" the public record […]