If You Expect Justice to Be Served on LAPD Sgt. Yanez, Prepare to Be Disappointed

(Author’s note: there is some editorializing in this story. The opinions are mine. Unless Bell is quoted saying something, don’t put my words in his mouth. – DN)

Following last Monday’s story detailing the likely role an LAPD Sargent took covering up his daughter’s deadly hit and run crash, Streetsblog received a lot of email. Letters from friends of the slain victim, Jesse Dotson, were the most common. But a depressing interchange with attorney Allan Bell, retired police officer and the Senior Trial Attorney at The Law Offices of Allen J. Bell & Associates, shows that the deck is stacked against justice when it comes to prosecuting Sgt. Arturo Yanez for his role in covering up his daughter’s crime.

Just a reminder, Jesse Dotson, by all accounts a decent and optimistic family man, was killed by a dangerous driver who left him laying in the street.

For those of you unfamiliar with the story, in late June Jesse Dotson was bicycling to work when he was struck by a hit and run driver. The car belonged to Vanessa Yanez, the daughter of LAPD Sgt. Arturo Yanez. Four hours after the crash, Yanez reported her car stolen and returned to a lot near her house. The crash occurred 16 miles away.

When the Gardena police charged Vanessa Yanez with a host of crimes, including vehicular manslaughter, bail was set at $100,000 but she was released on her own recognizance despite the fact that the police believe she killed someone, ran from the crime, and lied about a stolen car.

As for Sgt. Yanez, he lives with his daughter and actually owns the car that killed Dotson. He either believes his daughter’s ridiculous story and is one of the worst investigative officers ever, or he is complicit in the scheme to report the car stolen. Gardena police state they are not investigating Sgt. Yanez, but LAPD opened its own investigation.

I was relieved that LAPD was investigating, but Bell set me straight that there is little good news for fans of traffic justice.

First, Bell easily refutes my claim from last week that the LAPD review could strengthen Gardena’s police department’s case against Sgt. Yanez.

“…they will not share the internal investigation report with other agencies,” Bell explained.  “It is protected as a police personnel file by statute and cannot be released as a matter of law.  There are motions that could be filed in court to address a potential release of the internal affairs file, but i highly doubt that fight will occur.”

But even if Yanez is as incompetent covering up his role in the first cover-up and manages to be convicted, Los Angeles will still be on the hook for his pension. Even a felony won’t stop the city from its obligation to pay for the retirement of a crooked cop.

“On LAPD, if you are already vested, i.e., have put in the time needed to qualify for a pension, lets say 20 years for example, and are convicted of a felony, either on duty or off duty, you still get your pension,” Bell continued. “There has been talk over the years to pass legislation to change this, but LAPD has a strong legislative presence.”

The best we can hope for is that the Gardena Police Department, who have been in the news for all the wrong reasons recently, rise to the occasion and properly investigate and charge the Sargent as well as the daughter. However, a mess or legal red tape might make investigation and prosecution nigh impossible.

Some people say that justice is blind. In this case, the blindfolds are made out of laws designed to protect law breaking cops.

  • Matt Ruscigno RD MPH

    Shocking, yet not. Two-tiered legal system.

  • El Barto


  • This guy’s name should be disgraced.

  • paul

    I’d like to know who the District Attorney is that’s assigned to represent the people of California against Vanessa Yanez in the criminal case.

    I’d also like to be informed regarding the criminal hearings of this case i.e. which courthouse and on what dates.

    We need to show up and let the people of justice system know that this shit is absolutely unacceptable.

  • calwatch

    Which is perpetuated by both parties. The Peace Officer’s Bill of Rights is one of the strongest police protection laws in the country. Democrats support them because they are indebted to unions and Republicans love cops because they support law and order. Don’t forget the Seargant will have the benefit of a union legal fund should he get tangled with the court system.

  • Common-Sense

    It looks like this writer is jumping to a lot of conclusions. Nobody can be responsible for their adult child’s actions. If so every criminals parents would be up on charges. Also the Sergeant wont be able to use the union legal defense, because those only apply to on duty incidents.

  • If it were just a crash, he wouldn’t be responsible. It’s the poorly done cover-up that he’s likely guilty of aiding and abetting.

  • Anonymous

    Yep. Getting a handle on the DAs is job one here. DAs have unconscionable amounts of power… but they don’t use it evenly. And yet in most places *they are elected officials*.

    Something can be done about the DAs. The DAs are the pressure point to fix this.


Today’s Headlines

Gardena Will Charge Vanessa Yanez in Hit and Run Death of Jesse Dotson (Daily News) Bike Nation Admits Los Angeles System Is Probably Not Going to Happen (DTLA News) “People Friendly” Slauson Boulevard Will Have Six Car Lanes (Curbed) Editorial: How About We Fix the Streets and Sidewalks, and THEN Wi-Fi? (Daily News) Biking in […]

Fixing the System That Abandoned Susanna Schick

(Friends of Susana’s have set up a ChipIn account to collect funds to help with medical bills.  You can donate, here.) By now you’ve probably heard the story. Susanna Schick was bicycling down Spring Street in the green buffered bike lane on Friday night, when she was harassed by the driver of a white Lexus. […]

Response to Venice Boardwalk Crash Should Be Model, Not Outlier

Saturday in the late afternoona, Nathan Lewis Campbell got in his car and created carnage on the Venice Boardwalk. The 38-year-old native of Colorado drove on to the boardwalk and swerved through the area injuring dozens and killing Italian Alice Gruppioni, a 32 year old newly waling barefoot on the beach next to her husband. They […]