In California’s 36th District, Transportation Emerges as a Major Issue

5_18_10_harman.jpgHarman meets labor.

"I’m on the team!…I’m right here on the Love Train with sisters and brothers in organized labor, the environmental movement and the business community to make this happen right now!" exclaimed incumbent Congresswoman Jane Harman at a rally yesterday for the 30/10 initiative at the Green Line Station near LAX.  (Watch her full speech, Streetscasted here.)  The 30/10 initiative would use federal loans and grants to leverage the half cent sales tax passed by L.A. County voters for transit projects to complete a thirty year program in 10.

5_18_10_wino.jpgWinograd at the Bikerowave. Photo: Bikeside

"I endorse the Cyclists’ Bill of Rights.  The first tenet is that cyclists should be able to travel safely and free of fear.  We need voices in Washington that are committed to this vision.  And I am committed to this vision."  Challenger Marcy Winograd asserted at the Bikerowave on Venice Boulevard on April 7, just before being endorsed by Bikeside. (Watch her full statement, from Scoop L.A.’s You Tube page.)  The Cyclists’ Bill of Rights is an expression of the twelve right that all cyclists deserve that was put together by the Bike Writers Collective.

In a way, the two statements and venues are symbolic of the campaigns and candidates vying for the Democratic nomination for Congress in the 36th Congressional District which includes much of the Westside and South Bay.  The well-heeled Harman, one of the richest members of Congress, is supported by much of the establishment, including the organized labor groups that surrounded her yesterday as well as most politicians and even the Sierra Club’s Political Action Committee.  Winograd is running to Harman’s left, with support from smaller, but community based organizations such as Bikeside, and the Progressive Democrats for America; and seems to be at home surrounded by riders and people at work.

But the two candidates’ positions also reflect a new political reality for candidates in Southern California.  Los Angeles now has an organized community dedicated to green transportation or Livable Streets causes.  It’s now smart politics to embrace transit and bike riding in the "Car Capital of America."  Both Harman and Winograd are embracing two key programs in the Livable Streets platform in Los Angeles: accelerating transit expansion and securing cyclist rights.

30/10 and the Campaign

But to be fair, each candidate has a history of "walking the walk" on these issues.  While yesterday’s 30/10 sometimes felt more like a Jane Harman rally, speakers representing labor as well as Denny Zane and Mayor Villaraigosa all made pitches to support Harman’s campaign; the Mayor has been including her in speeches as the first Member of Congress to support 30/10 for months.  Senator Boxer, also up for re-election, may have grabbed the headlines on 30/10 because she’s more in a position to make some of the changes needed to see the proposal move forward; but the Mayor claims that it’s Harman who first said that Congress could make this happen for Los Angeles.

For Harman, the issue seems to be as much about jobs as it is a transportation vision for Los Angeles.  Given the high unemployment rate for the city and especially the labor movement, Harman’s positioning of 30/10 as a jobs creation program makes sense, but Measure R and 30/10 are about a lot more than just getting people back to work.  It’s about changing the DNA of L.A.’s transportation network and how Angelenos think of our city and county.

Harman has been a supporter of expanding transit, fighting hard for funds to study extending the Green Line and to build the Torrance Transit Center.  She’s been a member of the "Green Line Coalition" dedicated to having the transit line connect directly to LAX and her earmark requests show a lean towards transit projects, with a minority of road projects, for both the transportation funding bill (SAFETEA-LU) and this year’s appropriations.

But Winograd is hardly silent on transit expansion or Measure R.  For Winograd, 30/10 is about both the transportation vision and the ability to remake the economy from "a permanent war economy" to a "green economy."  Winograd writes,

Certainly, California pays its fair share of taxes, with virtually half
of our tax money subsidizing perpetual war policies championed by my
opponent, Jane Harman. For every million dollars she voted to invest in
the Iraq invasion or the Afghanistan occupation, we could have doubled
the number of jobs had we invested the same money in mass transit.

Congress, I will fight for federal dollars, low-interest bonds, to
construct 30/10 transit projects that will help us get where we really
need to go – sustainability. We need light rail, affordable buses, and
safe bike lanes to get us out of our cars and into a new frame of mind.

For a full copy of her statement to Streetsblog, click here.


Meanwhile, Winograd has the enthusiastic support of the only bicycle group that’s made an endorsement thus far, Bikeside.  Here again, we see a candidate who truly believes in cycling as a mode choice.  Her enthusiastic embrace of the Cyclists Bill of Rights isn’t just posturing, Winograd’s campaign seems to invite her supporters to a bike ride every week.  Whether it’s part of 350 Day, a tour of Venice’s urban gardens, or a trip to the Bikerowave, it seems that the Winograd campaign can’t wait to get people to join the candidate on a ride.  Not that embracing cycling on the Westside doesn’t make political sense.  Six months ago, there were no cycling groups with the ability to actively support a candidate without risking their non-profit status.  Today, there are two groups and cyclists are ready to "bike the vote" in L.A. like never before.

But it’s one thing to be a politician who happens to ride a bike and to be a politician who supports cycling legislatively.  Winograd has pledged to make the Cycling Bill of Rights a guiding principle of her transportation policy in Washington, D.C.  She’s gone so far as to promise federal support for community bike co-ops, similar to the Bicycle Kitchen, Bike Oven, Bikerowave, and Valley Bikery,.

In her decades in Congress, Harman doesn’t have the record to match Winograd’s rhetoric; although the Congresswoman is one of the 182 members of the Congressional Bike Caucus.  When looking for a signature "bike vote," I was only able to find support for the "fringe benefit" for bicycle commuters which created a small, monthly tax write-off for people who choose to commute via bicycle.  A search for the word "bicycle" on her website reveals, well, nothing.


As Measure R and 30/10 move forward, more and more politicians are going to be talking transit in the coming years.  Whether support for local transit projects leads to a solid vote for a "green transportation policy" out of Southern California remains to be seen.  Already in the 36th District, we’re seeing a race to champion transportation that’s both green and clean in the race for the Democratic Congressional Nomination.

  • Marcotico

    “I endorse the Cyclists’ Bill of Rights. The first tenant is that cyclists should be able to travel safely and free of fear.” I think you meant “tenet” which is a belief or position. Sorry I almost never nitpick, but this one is a pet peeve of mine.

  • Myla Reson

    High School teacher and educator Marcy Winograd is also endorsed by labor including her union, United Teacher of Los Angeles (UTLA), The ILWU Southern California District Council, and many others.
    While Jane Harman tries to burnish her green credidentials, we must not look away from the enormous carbon footprint left by the perpetual wars that Harman consistently votes to fund.
    Harman’s vote for the Peru free trade agreement was the petroleum industry’s wet dream, opening vast areas of previously protected Amazon rain forest open to oil and gas exploration.
    Myla Reson
    Venice, California

  • I really hate Helicopter Jane Harman. She picked out my old congressional district (where I grew up), helicoptered in with all her D.C. defense industry contacts, and has voted corporatist democrat ever since. Winograd has made several valid attempts at her seat, and I pray that this is the year she gets that hack kicked out of office. You can never underestimate Harman, however. She’s got big dollar bill signs and moral corruption all over everything she does.

  • The problem is, the 36th Congressional has always been a fairly moderate district.

    It’s not as much of a swing district as it used to be when it still included Palos Verdes, but will Torrance voters vote for Winograd if she wins the primary? Or will they vote for whoever wins the Republican nomination?

    Harman’s not perfect, but she’s often been better than the “drill baby drill” alternative …

  • 36th was moderate back when it was full of aerospace industry employees… it is now filled with entertainment industry employees and it probably one of the most liberal majority white district in California besides Marin County (Nancy Pelosi). Harmon is pretty conservative for her district and in this anti-incumbency election year, she is rip for some stiff primary challenge.

  • knixphan

    I now live in the 36th, and I don’t want anyone who supported Bush policies representing me and calling themselves a ‘Democrat’. Marcy Winograd has my vote all the way. Jane Harman is republican-lite.

  • Jim Smith

    I am a bike commuter and mass transit advocate but I think it’s wrong to evaluate and vote for a candidate on a single issue. We bike riders also care about endless wars, spying on American citizens and rampant militarism. I don’t care if Harman has a bike in every one of her homes, she still won’t get my vote.

  • Jane Harman will say anything to get peoples votes, but then she goes and votes with the conservative and Blue Dogs. She may have good voting record on envmntl issues but when she sides with the forces of neo-conservtism she is limiting the possibilities for transportation advocates and bicyclists nationwide while perpetuating the car and weapons culture mentality.

    Marcy Winograd is the only real choice for a sustainable future.


CD 36 Candidate Survey: Marcy Winograd

When Congress Woman Jane Harman announced her resignation earlier this year, two of California’s political heavyweights moved quickly to try and position themselves as the frontrunner for the suddenly vacant Congressional seat.  However, many members of the 36th District were excited because they believed Harman’s absence would create an opening for Marcy Winograd, a progressive […]

The Weekend in Livable Streets Events

Because I skipped doing the "Week in Livable Streets Events," I missed writing about some of the events that are going on this weekend.  In addition to the Bike to Work Week events in Pasadena, Culver City, and Glendale tomorrow; there are a couple of events this weekend that deserve a little more attention than […]

Today’s Headlines

Jane Harman and 30/10 Seem to have momentum. Fox Business Makes the Case for Higher Gas Tax Villaraigosa: Texting While Driving = Bad (LAist, HuffPo, AP) Rutten: 30/10 Most Important Initiative of Villaraigosa (LAT) Zev: We’re "on Track" for the Subway to Westwood Before 2020 (Press Release) Subtlety Abandoned: The Source Uses Three Exclamation Points […]