Council Moves Forward with EIR for Wilshire Boulevard

11_13_08_wilshire_bus.jpgBus lane free. Photo: LA Wad/Flickr

Yesterday’s full Los Angeles City Council meeting ran
extraordinarily late due to a potential lawsuit between the Controller
and the City Attorney. The council’s Transportation Committee meeting, previewed last week here and here, was scheduled for 2:00 P.M. but didn’t begin until after 4:30 P.M. By then,
most of the Department of Transportation (LADOT) staff had left.
Remaining were a little more than half of the initial 30+
yellow-t-shirt clad Bus Riders Union members, a half-dozen Comstock
Hills homeowners, and a couple of bicyclists.

Committee Chair Bill Rosendahl apologized profusely for the delay,
and, with fellow committee members Alarcón, Koretz and LaBonge in
attendance, immediately launched into the most contentious agenda item:
the LADOT’s recommendation that the city move forward with full
environmental review of the federally-funded peak hour bus-only lanes on Wilshire Boulevard.

Paul Koretz is the newly elected Council Member representing the
city’s 5th district, which includes the Comstock Hills, aka the
"condo canyon," stretch of Wilshire between Beverly Hills and UCLA. The
bulk of the opposition to the bus-only lane project has come from this
area. Among the committee, Koretz was the most openly skeptical of the
project – asking a number of questions, including if the project is a
"disaster" could it be removed? LADOT staff responded that they "didn’t
want to go there" and reassured Koretz that their calculations showed a
very modest impact on traffic. DOT stated that estimates show a
3-5 minute delay for cars driving the entire corridor, with a
corresponding 24% reduction in the time it takes for a bus to go the
same length.  Koretz ultimately moved the motion to fund the environmental study at Rosendahl’s suggestion.

Council Member LaBonge questioned whether the route could go to other
high-volume destination centers like Century City;  LADOT countered
that Wilshire itself is a destination-rich corridor, indeed "the number
one bus line in the United States."

Four Bus Riders Union speakers testified in support of the project
and the important precedent it will set. Speakers representing the
Green L.A. Transportation Working Group and the Los Angeles County
Bicycle Coalition also spoke in favor. Homeowners expressed their
displeasure at the planned bus lanes which they stated would
be "dangerous" for residents getting into and out of
driveways, and negatively impact trash trucks, mail delivery,
ambulances, and fire engines.

Rosendahl diplomatically thanked speakers for raising important
issues and suggested that the full Environmental Impact Report (EIR)
process would be where all these benefits and costs can get full public
airing. The committee unanimously approved the motion for the project
EIR to proceed, including directing LADOT to report back in 90 days.
The motion (08-2595-S1) will now be scheduled for a vote of the full city council.

Running very late, the committee then spent less than three minutes
approving LADOT’s proposed contract for ShelterCLEAN to maintain the
Orange Line Bike Path (09-2120) and continued the rest of the agenda to future meetings.

(Editor’s Note: Linton is Chair of the Green L.A. Transportation Working Group and is an unabashed supporter of the Wilshire Bus-Only Lanes project.)

  • I’m pretty sure that emergency vehicles can use “bus-only” lanes when their sirens are flashing. If by “negatively impact” the residents mean “will help them get their faster” they are correct.

  • Tim

    Why don’t they start with repaving that minefield? Wilshire kills cars and swallows bicyclists.

  • This project includes funding to repave the worse stretch of Wilshire–Wilton to La Brea.

  • Boy, I hope the “condo canyon” folks realize that re-dedicating roadway space to a rapid bus lane (and BIKE LANES?) will help move more people more efficiently – and if done properly will reduce the number of private vehicles blasting by their doors on a daily basis.

  • As perhaps their harshest critics, I do want to acknowledge the BRU has been very proactive on supporting the lanes these past few years including having members speak at the sort of wait forever to get your pittance of speaking time meetings the city seems to be best at doing.

    I see the Comstock Hills opposition being of the “we are too rich to have to put up with THAT in our neighborhood” variety a la the battle over El Toro. The actual pros and cons are secondary to all that for them.

  • Koretz wasted no time picking up the NIMBY torch.

  • @bzcat – I wouldn’t say that Koretz picked up a NIMBY torch. He is certainly under a lot of pressure to… but at the end of the day, he did do what I consider the right thing – he voted for the project to proceed. I bet he takes heat for this… so I think that those of us who support the environment and mobility in L.A. should be praising his action.

    @Damien – I agree that many of the homeowner concerns express were difficult to take seriously. I suspect that it’s likely to be easier for an ambulance to access the site with a dedicated bus lane.

  • RayS

    Tom LaBonge popped into last night’s meeting of the Greater Wilshire Neighborhood Council meeting and the question of resurfacing Wilshire “curb to curb” from Wilton to La Brea came up. According to the councilmember’s aide, resurfacing would start in July 2010.

    The “bus-only” lanes were not mentioned which leads me to believe the resurfacing will happen whether or not the transit project is approved. The outside lanes are in such bad condition now (according to LaBonge in addition to the thousands of heavy buses traversing the street the water table is unusually high in that area) they are virtually unusable. (Even the Metro buses avoid them when possible.)

  • Today, the Wilshire Bus-Only Lane motion was scheduled to be heard by the full City Council on Tuesday September 22nd.


Council Approves Moving Forward With Wilshire Bus Lanes

Bus lane free. Photo: LA Wad/Flickr The city of Los Angeles’ Wilshire Boulevard Bus-Only Lane project took another step forward at this morning’s full city council hearing. The project would implement peak-hour bus-only lanes from Pico Union to Santa Monica. It’s calculated to speed bus times by about 25%. More information at Metro’s project website. Last week, despite […]

Council Committee Set to Debate Wilshire BRT Project

You knew it was bound to happen. The Brentwood Community Council, the community group fighting the last remaining portion of the Wilshire Bus Only Lanes project planned for the Westside, is seizing on a seemingly innocuous motion on today’s Transportation Committee Meeting.  The motion asks for the LADOT to study the impacts of the Metro […]

Wilshire Bus-Only Lanes Move the Environmental Review Stage

It won’t be separated as this BRT in the PRC, but it will be nice.  Photo:我爱铰接巴士/Flickr Sometimes I enjoy having dinner at the Wilshire/Western Denny’s for the opportunity it affords to watch the amazing dynamic transit action occurring at that intersection. This includes frequent and very busy bus lines (local and Rapid) along both streets plus hoards of […]