Bipartisan Pandering on Congestion Pricing

solis.jpg
Three Democratic Congress Members, Grace Napolitano of Santa Fe Springs, Hilda Solis of El Monte and Diane Watson of Los Angeles, have joined a pair of suburban Republicans in sponsoring federal legislation that would effectively end Metro’s efforts to put HOT Lanes on the 10, 110 and 210 highways.

Bi-partisan or not, the Members of Congress are showing a lack of understanding of both congestion pricing and the process going forward.

The Whittier Daily News quotes Solis as saying:

This plan could transfer traffic from the freeways to our residential neighborhoods, posing significant and unnecessary safety and public health risks.

The effect of moving a significant amount of traffic off the highways and on to surface streets, the Solis Effect, has never been documented in cases where congestion pricing has gone into effect.  If Solis had done her research, she would have found that congestion pricing actually improves public health by reducing congestion and air pollution.Of course, understanding the relationship between car culture and pollution would require actually admitting that there’s something unhealthy about driving cars.  A thought alien to residents of third world countries, the Daily News and Members of Congress.Solis goes on:

Rather than rush this plan through the process, the MTA should allow the public an opportunity to learn more about it and discuss its potential impacts.

Metro’s HOT Lanes proposal has to be approved by both houses of the state legislature and the California Transportation Commission before the end of this year.  Solis’ statement shows she either doesn’t understand the process or believes that the United States Congress is the best place to debate local issues.If federal lawmakers want to oppose Metro’s HOT Lanes plan, they should offer an alternative.  If they want to deny Metro the funding for additional buses and park-and-rides they had best be working on earmarks to get LA County the funds to replace the funds they lost.

Photo:Wikipedia 

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Congestion Charging on the Horizon for China’s Cities

|
Which Chinese city will be the first to try congestion pricing? Beijing, Guangzhou, Shanghai — megacities whose populations are on the scale of New York’s? Or second-tier but still mighty cities (think Chicago) like Hangzhou, Nanjing, or Xi’an? Road tolling à la American turnpikes and thruways is already extensive in China, as a means to […]

City Considering Congestion Parking for the Downtown

|
Photo:Spacing Magazine/Flickr A lot has been said over some of the items on today’s City Council Transportation Committee hearing, most of it bad, but there is one agenda item we haven’t yet touched on that could have a huge impact on traffic and congestion in Los Angeles. Under the innocuous headlines "Funding Agreements for Congestion […]

City Watch Columnist Slams Congestion Pricing

|
Mid-City activist Charles Tarlow wrote a stirring, grass roots call to arms in this week’s City Watch. Unfortunately, Tarlow’s piece rails against congestion pricing and trots out some tired arguments that have been repeatedly debunked. It wraps opposition to one of the most environmentally friendly transportation planning choices in the flag, arguing that one of […]