City Councilmembers Want Rules for Ghost Bikes and Roadside Memorials

Members of the East Side Riders and Los Ryderz bike clubs put a ghost bike up at the site where a cyclist was hit by the Blue Line train in March of 2013. (photo courtesy of John Jones III)

(Note: An earlier version of this story mis-identified the Council Member who introduced the motion as Mitch O’Farrell. It was introduced by Mitch Englander. Streetsblog deeply regrets this error.)

Sometimes, a crash is so terrible that a permanent memorial is created. Other times, family and friends will erect a temporary memorial with flowers, pictures and religious symbols. When a bicyclist is slain in a crash, advocates such as Danny Gamboa, Aktive, the Eastside Riders, and Los Ryderz, the city’s bicycle co-ops or any number of people or groups may chain up a haunting white “ghost bike” at the crash site.

How a city should respond to roadside memorials for pedestrians, car passengers and cyclists killed in crashes has been a difficult question. How long is too long? At what point does a memorial become a nuisance? When should a city step in and clean it up?

While my personal answer to such a question is “never,” unless it poses a safety hazard of some sort, the lack of firm rules often leads to police, or sanitation officials, or just a local resident or business taking down a memorial without notice. This leaves the family of the victims feeling angry and violated again.

Sometimes a memorial goes back up. Sometimes it doesn’t.

Councilmembers Mitch Englander and Joe Buscaino have written a motion calling on the city to create rules regarding the maintenance and removal of memorials. Current law orders the Bureau of Sanitation to remove “all items blocking the public right-of-way.” In New York City, a 2010 law allowing the removal of “derelict” bicycles was amended to all “ghost bikes” to stay up, so there is precedent for major cities to enact memorial friendly legislation.

A common time frame for removal is “90 days” in other cities. Tempe, Arizona has such an ordinance, but the memorials often last much longer. But when San Diego removed the ghost bike dedicated to a popular activist nearly half-a-year after the memorial was created, the community reacted with outrage.

Sometimes even half a year isn’t enough time to say goodbye, or to remove a memorial that doubles as a piece of traffic calming.

While neither office has gone “on the record” on this motion, casual conversation with staff confirms that the goal is to create a consistent and predictable policy that leans towards leaving such memorials up for longer periods of time.

4_27_09_die_in.jpgThere are lots of Flickr sets from the 2009 die-in at Castillo’s at the Ghost Bike.  This picture is from Alex Thompson’s but there are also good ones at  Ensie’s and Streetsblog’s.

It should be noted that Councilmember Buscaino’s staff includes John Jones III, one of the founders of the Eastside Riders. Eastside Riders is one of the groups that helps create Ghost Bike memorials.

So if we take the Councilmembers’ motion at face value, what would you like a final set of regulations to look like? Leave thoughts in the comments section. I’ll leave some of mine there as well.

  • poopface

    It is Englander not O’Farrell. Terrible reporting.

  • Walt Arrrrr

    Every Ghost Bike should be accompanied by a comprehensive study of the
    given roadway, followed by re-engineering that would implement
    contemporary safety measures to effectively prevent all future tragedies.

  • Yikes. That is a pretty egregious error. My apologies and it’s been corrected.

  • AJ

    “Note: An earlier version of this story mis-identified the Council Member who introduced the motion as Mitch O’Farrell. It is introduced by Mitch O’Farrell. Streetsblog deeply regrets this error.”

    I think you meant to say Englander once again.

  • tragicsandwich

    I’m not sure the correction was made the way you intended.

  • sahra

    it’s been updated, thanks!

  • DTLARes

    What year was the bicyclist hit? The photo caption says “March 2014.”

  • sahra

    good catch. it was 2013. i’ll make the change.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Gardena PD Ticket, Harass United Riders of South Los Angeles for Taking Lane while the Case of the Hit-and-Run Victim They Were Honoring Remains Unsolved

|
22400 (a) vc Impeding Traffic from Danny and Kat ZKO on Vimeo. The United Riders of South Los Angeles had just left the memorial site for Benjamin Torres, killed last October in Gardena in a hit-and-run, when they were pulled over by the Gardena Police Department. They had stopped at the site to replace Torres’ […]

Art Opening: Ghost Bikes of L.A.

|
LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA – Opening Friday, October 24, 2013 The international art movement begun in 2003 celebrates ten years of art, advocacy and community with the first ever gallery show. Family members, Ghost Bike and transportation advocates, artists and friends will be in attendance. Ghost Bikes are memorials honoring cyclists who are fatally – or […]

Hundreds of Cyclists Stage Die-In at Jesus Castillo’s Ghost Bike

|
There are lots of Flickr sets from Friday’s memorial at the Ghost Bike.  This picture is from Alex Thompson’s but you should also check out Ensie’s and Streetsblog’s. Last Friday, participants in Los Angeles Critical Mass, members of the local community and other assorted transportation activists all gathered at Los Angeles’ newest Ghost Bike for […]