Skip to Content
Streetsblog Los Angeles home
Streetsblog Los Angeles home
Log In
E Line (Expo Line)

Already 0 for 2, Neighbors for Smart Rail Take Their Case to the CA Supreme Court

9:21 AM PDT on June 4, 2012

Photo: ##http://www.flickr.com/photos/29300710@N08/4929656005/sizes/z/in/set-72157624689252327/##LA Streetsblog/Flickr##

The question of how far Neighbors for Smart Rail, a coalition of homeowners and community groups fighting the expansion of the Expo Line into West Los Angeles, were willing to take their legal challenges to the line is now answered.  They're willing to take it all the way.

Last week, NFSR appealed to the California Supreme Court to overturn a decision of the 2nd Appellate Division of the California Superior Courts to uphold the environmental documents supporting the construction of Phase II of the Expo Line.  Phase II of the Expo Line will pick up where Phase I ends in Culver City and extend the line to Downtown Santa Monica.  The Supreme Court has not announced whether it will hear arguments or issue a ruling in the case.

While NFSR has many complaints with the Expo Line and how the line was approved; court watchers are pointing to one specific complaint that has likely caught the Supreme Court's attention: "The Baseline Issue."  NFSR has argued in two court rooms that the Expo Authority used an improper baseline for analyzing the impacts of the Expo Line on automobile traffic, air quality and greenhouse gas emissions.  The Expo Construction Authority evaluated the impacts on conditions it projected to exist in 2030. NFSR argues that instead of future conditions the Authority needed to look at current conditions as its baseline, not ones from an uncertain future.

NFSR's legal team points to two cases Madera Oversight Coalition, Inc. v. County of Madera (5th District Court of Appeals, 2011) and Sunnyvale West Neighborhood Assn. v. City of Sunnyvale City Council (6th District Court of Appeals, 2010) where state appellate courts ruled that agencies cannot use future conditions as a baseline when evaluating the environmental impacts of proposed projects.

The Second Appellate Court didn't just reject the argument affirmed by the other courts, it emphatically rejected it.

So it's not a surprise that the Supreme Court could step in.  While there are clear differences between Sunnyvale, Madera and the current case; it makes sense for the top court in California to make a definitive statement on what can, and what can't, be used as a baseline in state mandated environmental studies.

Regardless of the outcome of this case, we're likely at the end of the road, legally speaking, for the challenges to the Expo Line.  Unless of course the court merely requires that the Authority re-do the environmental studies with a new baseline.  If it stops construction while it waits for the new study, such a ruling could add years to the opening date of Phase II.  If it orders a new study but doesn't stay construction, then all of these legal challenges could end up resulting in new studies and more chances to have more legal challenges.

(Note: The Expo Construction Authority does not comment on active lawsuits.  NFSR representatives were asked to comment for this story but did not respond by publication time.)

(Note 2: An earlier version of this story implied that the Supreme Court had already decided to take up the case.  That is not true and the story has been altered slightly to reflect that.  Thanks, Jonathan.)

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog Los Angeles

Rundown of New Federal Reconnecting Communities Grants for L.A. County

There are seven L.A. County Reconnecting Communities grants totaling $162 million - about 90% of that goes to Metro's Removing Barriers project, which includes new bus lanes, first/last mile walk/bike facilities, bike-share, and more.

March 19, 2024

Where L.A. City Will Add New Bus-Only Lanes

New bus lanes are coming to Broadway, Colorado Blvd., Crenshaw Blvd, Lincoln Blvd., Los Feliz Blvd., Santa Monica Blvd., Valley Blvd., Vermont Avenue, Westwood Blvd., Whittier Blvd. and many more city streets!

March 15, 2024
See all posts