A Call for Civility and a Change in L.A. Streetsblog’s Comments Moderation Policy


Image: ##http://amuseorbemused.com/2012/02/flashback-t-fiddlesticks/##Amuse or Bemused##

For years, Los Angeles Streetsblog has had one of the loosest set of rules governing our comments section.  In the four and a half years we’ve been publishing, we’ve maybe deleted 10 comments (not including spam) that were too over the top, slanderous, or sexist to let stand.

However, in recent months, we’ve noticed some warning flags. In some comment threads the language is getting a little more abusive. In other ones, people are mis-representing who they are.* It’s time to make a change before things get out of hand.

As of right now, we’re going from a policy that was basically “don’t be racist, sexist or say something that can get us sued” to the policy used by all the other Streetsblogs. That policy can be read here.

So, who decides whether a comment has “ad hominem attacks, unnecessary or uncreative profanity, off-topic posts, lengthy or poorly written rants, flat-earth arguments, etc…”? We do. If an article is written by Kris Fortin or Sahra Sulaiman, they will have the ability to edit or moderate the comments. If it’s written by anyone else, that power resides with me (or if I’m away, whoever is the acting editor in my place.)

And yes, a comment written by someone who is logged in or well known might get more leeway than an anonymous one of one by a first time poster.

Personally, I hate moderating comments. The decision to change our policy was not made lightly. We discussed it at our most recent Board Meeting and it was unanimously decided that we needed to make a change.  When we meet in the fall, we’ll see how the policy is working and make tweaks if we need to. We don’t want to stifle debate, but to encourage a healthier and civilized one.

If you have any comments, questions, or want to tell me where to stick this policy, you all know how to express yourselves.


 *- (I mean, I can see the url’s, there’s no point in having a conversation with yourself…)


Changes at Streetsblog in 2015

When Streetsblog launched in 2006, the site made an impact almost immediately. The daily scrutiny of NYC transportation agencies and elected officials created new opportunities for policy reform, leading to real change in the design and operation of our streets. It wasn’t long before advocates from out of town contacted Streetsblog about bringing this model […]

Happy Birthday, Streetsblog Network

One year ago today, we announced the launch of the Streetsblog Network — a national and international network of blogs covering transportation policy, sustainable planning, smart growth and active transportation. We conceived of the network as a way to get people who are passionate about these issues literally on the same page. We started with […]

Much Ado About Nothing? New State Rules for “Pay-As-You-Drive” Insurance (Updated at 4:07 P.M. Below)

I’m guessing his car insurance would be higher than mine. Photo: Clubjuggler/Flickr Last week, State Insurance Commissioner Steve Poizner announced that his commission adopted new rules allowing and encouraging auto insurance companies to create "pay as you drive" (PAYD) insurance policies. PAYD policies, which charge drivers per mile driven for their insurance, provide another financial […]

Bike Saturday Around Los Angeles

Back in the day, I used to occasionally write "Bike Weekend" posts when there were multiple great events going on at the same time. Ever since I started writing "The Week in Livable Streets Events" on Monday, I’ve stopped doing those. However, this weekend there are three events going on across the city, at nearly […]

Shaping the 2009 Transpo Debate: Rockefeller Foundation’s Nick Turner

American transportation policy has not fundamentally changed since gasoline cost a nickel a gallon and President Eisenhower started building out the Interstate highway system. Today, with gas prices through the roof, gridlock grinding our cities to a halt and many Americans feeling trapped in barely affordable, far-flung, exurban homes, it’s clear that our 1950’s-era transportation […]