LACBC: Send County Bike Plan Back to the Drawing Board

Late last year, a team of advocates descended on City Hall to urge the City’s Planning Commission to reject the most recent draft of the city’s bike plan for a variety of issues, ranging from equity to the vague nature of the goals and timeline for implementation.  The Los Angeles County Bicycle Coalition is hoping for a  re-run as the L.A. County Bike Plan heads to the County Planning Commission with many of the same issues needing resolution that the city’s plan had last year at this time.

To read the plan, ## here.

This Wednesday morning (full event details at the end of the post), the County Planning Commission will meet at 9:00 A.M. to discuss the draft Bike Plan and the Los Angeles County Bicycle Coalition is urging cyclists to urge the Commission to send the plan back to the staff for further revisions.  To help advocates better lobby the County Planning Commission, the LACBC created an action alert on Google Documents for individuals or organizations.

The LACBC summarizes on its blog:

“…while this plan does provide 816 miles of new bikeways  for the many unincorporated communities in LA County, the majority are bike routes (458). We feel the plan still needs a number of improvements, including more miles of bike lanes and bike boulevards (also referred to as bicycle friendly streets) before any action should be taken on it.”

The Bike Plan has been in the works since 2009, but this run to the L.A. County Planning Commission feels a bit rushed with recent developments not being taken into account.  Most notably, we’re just weeks removed from the triumphant launch of a “Model Design Manual for Living Streets” written by a team of experts including bike planner Ryan Snyder.

The manual showed how any municipality could embrace a living streets philospohy to encourage greater physical activity and a more equitable mix of transportation modes.  Funding for the Manual came from the L.A. County Public Health Department, yet neither the manual nor its street designs are part of the L.A. County Bike Plan.

It’s time for the County’s left and right hands to get an idea of what the other is doing.

But that’s not the only problem with the current plan.  Repeating the mistakes of the rejected draft of the city’s draft plan one year ago, the County Bike Plan is wobbly on a timeline and hard goals for the project.  In January of 2010, I wrote about the difficulties facing a Bike Plan, or any plan, that doesn’t have firmly defined goals, objectives, strategies and tactics.  Of the then-draft of the City Bike Plan, I wrote:

My main concern with this plan doesn’t have to do with what routes do or don’t appear, there are many cyclists more familiar with Los Angeles’ streets than I am and I would pay close attention to their comments on this matter.  Instead, I am worried that this isn’t really what can be considered a “plan” at all.  A plan has deadlines, designates who is responsible for what, has a list of goals, objectives, strategies and tactics, and most importantly identifies a source or sources of funding to make the goals, objectives, strategies and tactics of the plan a reality.

Bike Plans are needed by municipal and county governments before they can apply for bicycle project grants from the state and federal governments.  The L.A. County Plan does the minimum that it has to to meet that objective, but L.A. County hasn’t passed a Bike Plan in 30 years, and the 11 million residents of the county deserve a plan that does more than outline a series of projects.  It should create a vision for a bicycle friendly county, and then the projects are designed to meet that goal.  For now, L.A. County is missing that mark, and for that reason the LACBC wants staff to take another crack at improving the plan before it moves on to final approval at the L.A. County Board of Supervisors.

Meeting Information:

LA County Planning Commission

Where: Hall of Records – Room 150
320 West Temple Street
Los Angeles, CA 90012

When: Wednesday, Nov 16th – 9am


L.A. County Working on Its Own Bike Master Plan

As a couple of people have pointed out to me, today the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors is voting on a $434,363 proposal to fund the creation of a county-wide Bike Master Plan.  Details are still sketchy at this point, but we do now the proposal calls for Alta Planning to devise the plan, […]

Planning Commission Leadership Strengthens Bike Plan

Yesterday morning, at its meeting at the Van Nuys City Hall, the city of Los Angeles’ Planning Commission approved the latest draft of the city’s Bike Plan. In November, the commission’s hearing was contentious and drawn-out, resulting in a vote to continue the plan, essentially sending it back to Planning Department for revisions. Yesterday’s hearing saw […]

LA County Planning Commission Hears Draft Bike Plan

Less than a month ago the LA County Department of Public Works released the “final” draft of the LA County Bike Plan , which focuses on the unincorporated communities in LA County. This coming Wednesday, November 16th the LA County Bike Plan will head to the Planning Commission. This is the first update to the County’s existing […]

Light Appears at the End of a Long Bike Plan Tunnel

The city of Los Angeles’ update to its 1996 Bicycle Master Plan has been years in the making, and it looks like there’s finally some light appearing at the end of the bike tunnel. City work began in 2007, with an initial round of public meetings in early 2008. Shifting 2009 drafts drew near-universal derision from local […]

Gov. 2.0? Activists Mimic Bike Plan Site

Which one is which? Images: and The other day, I noticed that some of the stories reviewing the Draft Bike Plan on Streetsblog were receiving incoming links from what I thought was the city’s Bike Plan Website.  Given the strong critiques of the plan and the city, I was surprised that the City […]