Transit Fare Inflation Hitting Health Insurance-Like Levels?

That’s the implication buried in a roundup
of dismal news from urban transit agencies that ran in Saturday’s Wall
Street Journal. After noting the overall ridership decreases tallied by APTA and the specter of punitive service cuts in many cities, the newspaper noted:

3811098633_86047dae97.jpgRiders
of Chicago’s El train, shown above, were spared fare hikes in 2010
thanks to a last-minute deal. (Photo: ~JudyCrawford via Flickr)

The cost of riding public transit rose at a 17.8% annual rate in the
six months ended in November, the Bureau of Labor Statistics reported.
Overall consumer prices were up at a 4.2% rate in the same period.

That statistic is a bit tricky, since it projects twelve-month inflation rates by looking at six months of data.

But
it’s still striking — and scary — to see transit fare inflation
hitting levels that look as bad as price increases for health
insurance, which in recent years has grown 8.7 percent faster than the annual inflation rate, according to the Kaiser Foundation.

Heading
into 2010, it’s easy to see urban transit agencies falling into a
vicious cycle driven by state budget woes verging on the apocalyptic, local resistance to fare increases that disproportionately affect non-car-owning commuters, and federal inaction on much-needed transportation reform.

If
there’s any upside to the grim picture, it may be that scarce funding
is likely to force lawmakers into honestly apportioning scarce
resources based on infrastructure projects’ true value to local
communities — not the political popularity of ribbon-cutting
ceremonies or promises of local job-creation that ultimately fail to materialize.

Such
an outcome could well put transit and road projects on a more equal
footing. But much like incremental emissions reductions taking shape
at the state level, any change will surely take longer than most
Americans would like. One thing that might help prod political leaders
into action: more of a spotlight on the Journal’s transit inflation
number.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Metro Board: Fare Gates, TAP But Regional Connector Postponed

|
(We just found out from Metro, via email and The Source, that the Regional Connector discussion is being moved until next month so “local concerns” can be addressed in the financial district. – DN) It wouldn’t be the Metro Board of Directors without some drama.  Read the full agenda for tomorrow’s meeting of the Board […]

What Factors Are Causing Metro’s Declining Ridership? What Next?

|
In my circles, there has been a lot of discussion swirling around Wednesday’s Los Angeles Times article, Billions spent, but fewer people are using public transportation in Southern California, by Laura Nelson and Dan Weikel. The Times’ authors cast a disparaging light on recent downturns in ridership: “Despite a $9-billion investment in new light rail […]

Metro Cutting Day Pass Cost Back to $5

|
One week ago, Metro CEO Art Leahy announced at the Transit Coalition monthly meeting that part of the money saved from cutting 305,000 hours of bus service would go towards reversing part of the 2010 fare increases by reducing the cost of a Metro Day Pass from $6 to $5.  With a Day Pass, a […]

For Metrolink It’s a 6% Fare Hike vs. Major Service Cuts

|
This was one of four cars on an Orange County Line run leaving Los Angeles Union Station to Orange County and Oceanside. It gets busier in Orange County.  Photo and description: LA Wad/Flickr Two weeks ago, I celebrated that the Metrolink Board agreed to "look into other options" rather than raise fares by 6%. Maybe […]