The Missed Opportunity For an Urban Stimulus: Mayors ‘Were Ignored’

wo-thirds
of America’s population, and more than three-quarters of its economic
productivity, come from major cities. So why did the Obama
administration’s economic stimulus law end up giving metropolitan areas
the short end of the stick?

Dan_Malloy1.JPGDaniel Malloy, Democratic mayor of Stamford, CT (Photo: Bridgeport City Council)

Harry Moroz of the Drum Major Institute attempts to answer the question this week in a new article
for The Atlantic. Talking with mayors from around the country, Moroz
heard deeply felt frustration from mayors in both parties about the
decision to route stimulus money — particularly for transportation —
through state capitals rather than cities:

During the bill’s conception, mayors stressed that a state-focused
stimulus would bring slow, inefficient results, and that more jobs
could be created if money were funneled directly to urban areas. In a report issued last winter,
the U.S. Conference of Mayors listed more than 15,000 “ready-to-go”
projects that could provide 1.2 million new jobs in just two years.

So what happened, exactly? “I think we were listened to,” says
Stamford, Connecticut, Mayor Daniel Malloy, who will run for governor
of his state as a Democrat in 2010. “I just think we were then ignored.
And I don’t think we were necessarily ignored by the president. I think
we were ignored by the Congress.”

Congress’ move to "ignore" city leaders, as Malloy put it, is all the
more surprising considering how many senior Democrats hail from
urbanized regions: think San Francisco, New York City, and the Washington D.C. area.

But no one can accuse the nation’s mayors of failing to speak up. In a February letter to Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood [PDF],
20 city chiefs urged that stimulus funding formulas send transportation
aid to metropolitan planning organizations (MPOs) from regions with
more than 200,000 residents as well as to state DOTs. Their pleas were
not heeded, however, and cities ultimately paid a price.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Freight Rail, Streetcars Are Tops in Stimulus’ TIGER Chase

|
The Obama administration today announced the winners of $1.5 billion stimulus in highly competitive stimulus grants under the program known as Transportation Investments Generating Economic Recovery, or TIGER. Southeastern and midwestern freight rail projects were the day’s biggest winners, with urban streetcar projects also making a big splash. Freight rail in Chicago, where the CREATE […]

BRU: No Fare Hikes Without Public Process

|
Image of "Times": Strategy Center/Flickr Earlier this morning, the Bus Rider’s Union rallied at the Wilshire/Western Transit Station to urge the Metro Board to not go forward with planned fare hikes for Metro bus and rail services until a full public hearing schedule is announced and executed. In May of 2007, the Metro Board adopted […]

Obama, Ethanol, and the “New Metropolitan Reality”

|
In a weekend speech to the U.S. Conference of Mayors, Senator Barack Obama continued to distinguish himself on urban policy, talking up cities as vital economic centers worthy of investment. Harry Moroz of DMI Blog has the story. Obama opened with a reference to his time as a community developer in Chicago and he joked […]

Media Praises I-405 Widening Project, Tough Questions Unanswered

|
Photo: Gentleman of Sophistication and Refinement/Flickr Last Friday, local media outlets participated in a rally for the Sepulveda Pass Widening Project, that would widen the I-405 to connect carpool lanes between the I-10 and I-101, with Governor Schwarzenegger, Mayor Villaraigosa and various other union and public officials.  Using an uncritical media to amplify their claims, […]

Schwarzenegger Proposes Making the 405 a Double Decker Freeway

|
To the casual observer, Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger seems like an environmental crusader.  He signs anti-sprawl legislation, he sues the federal government over emission standards for automobiles, he flies around the world to attend greenhouse gas conferences. But to those of us that live here and have been working to clean and green our transportation system; […]