New Report: Feds Subsidizing Parking Six Times as Much as Transit

tax_expenditure_employee_transportation_benefits.pngBoth Images: Subsidyscope

"Subsidy" is a word used quite often in transportation policy-making circles, whether by road acolytes who claim (falsely)
that highways are not federally subsidized because of the gas tax or by
transit boosters who lament Washington’s unceasing focus on paying for
more local asphalt.

But the subsidy debate often overlooks the government tax
exemption for workers’ parking expenses. And federal parking subsidies
are skyrocketing, as Subsidyscope revealed yesterday in its data-packed
report on
U.S. transport spending: the value of tax-free parking will reach $3
billion this year, compared with $500 million in subsidies for transit

The imbalance might be corrected if the government
treated parking and transit equally when it came to tax benefits.
Workers can write off a maximum of slightly more than $200 in monthly
parking benefits, while the maximum tax-free value of transit passes is
about $100 less per month.

Subsidyscope, a joint project of the Pew Charitable Trusts and the Sunlight Foundation , pored over federal records to produce a searchable database
of transportation spending dating back to the year 2000. Their
researchers’ conclusions found that highways received $30 billion in
federal support last year — more than three times as much as transit,
which got $9 billion.

How much of that $30 billion was a
subsidy? It’s tough to say, according to Subsidyscope, since state DOTs
are not required to report the details of how federal road aid is
distributed. Still, the overwhelming majority of federal transport
programs contain subsidies (see the chart after the jump for more

A more classic example of federal subsidy is
programs that transfer the risk of new projects onto the federal
government. The Transportation Infrastructure Finance and Innovation
Act (TIFIA), which offers
loans to states and localities at a low interest rate, is the transport
sector’s major source of credit subsidies from Washington — and the
majority of TIFIA loans go to highway projects.

  • Brent

    “How much of that $30 billion was a subsidy? It’s tough to say … ”

    Subsidy levels are such a critical point in the debate over transportation spending; I wish someone would come up with a definitive comparison. I suppose there might be a definitional issue, too, but to me the minimum definition is money allocated to a program that comes directly from the general fund, rather than from some fee levied on the users of the program.

  • The Eastside Bike Club attended this event and had a blast! It was fun and innovative. This event brought a diverse group of Angelinos that explored the South Central community and educated many of us on what goes on in that community straight from the people who live there.

    We found out from Steven Box that the word KRUSH in Africa means “Embrace”

    The Eastside Bike Club will be hosting the next “DISCOVER LOS ANGELES BIKE TOUR RIDE” in the near future. We are calling it the “EASTSIDE ABRAZO” Ride we will begin to plan our route and distinctive stops we will be making along this ride to show the history, culture and taste of the “EASTSIDE”

    The EASTSIDE BIKE CLUB host two rides a week on Tuesday nights at 7pm and Saturday mornings at 8am. We encourage all to visit our website follow us on and to email us at to find out about all of our rides and the upcoming “EASTSIDE ABRAZO”