Ad Nauseam: What “Cash for Clunkers” Hath Wrought

The government’s Cash for Clunkers program officially begins today,
but car dealers have been running ads like this one for a while
already. They have to keep the public informed: Now you can trade in
your old car and buy a brand-new SUV or pick-up truck with a hefty
assist from Uncle Sam.

Here we have the government spending
a billion dollars on about 250,000 vouchers for individual car buyers.
Ostensibly, the purpose is to save some jobs and cut some emissions.
Meanwhile, we’re in the middle of a budget crisis affecting transit agencies serving 22 million Americans. Green jobs
and emissions-reducing transportation are on the line. When DOT
Secretary LaHood holds his press event on Monday touting the roll-out
of Cash for Clunkers, someone should ask him how the Obama
administration can justify this dubious car industry subsidy while
hanging transit riders out to dry.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

A Last Word on Cash for Clunkers…We Promise

|
One thing the government’s CARS program — a.k.a. "cash for clunkers" — has clearly stimulated is commentary. For a policy involving a shade under $3 billion in federal spending, it has enjoyed no shortage of media coverage. (Photo: Newsday) In part this is because the program looks like a big success, and certainly congressional leaders […]
STREETSBLOG USA

GAO: Economic Recovery Benefits of ‘Cash for Clunkers’ Are ‘Uncertain’

|
"Cash for clunkers," the White House’s much-touted program encouraging trade-ins for more fuel-efficient autos, had an "uncertain" impact on economic recovery, according to a new audit from the independent Government Accountability Office (GAO) — largely because it remains unclear how many of the car sales it spurred would have occurred without taxpayer subsidies. Were "clunker" […]
STREETSBLOG USA

Brookings: “Cash for Clunkers” Wasn’t Worth It

|
Turns out paying people to buy cars isn’t a great policy for the economy or the environment. That’s the determination of a pair of Brookings Institution researchers who evaluated the effectiveness of the 2009 Cash for Clunkers program. The $2.85 billion program, part of President Obama’s economic stimulus package, produced only 2,050 “job-years,” according to researchers […]

Separating Myth from Fact on “Cash for Clunkers”

|
As debate rages on in the capital over whether to keep assisting the auto industry by giving out more "cash for clunkers" rebates, two assertions are becoming commonplace: the program is helping diminish U.S. oil consumption, and the program is not paid for with new money. (Photo: AP) The first argument was reiterated on Friday […]