The High Cost of Subsidized Parking at Cal Tech

12_08_08_caltech.jpg

Over the weekend, I was drawn to a fantastic post on the real cost of subsidized parking at Cal Tech in Pasadena by Zane Selvans, who’s name should be familiar to readers who frequent the Streetsblog comments section.  Zane’s post has an incredibly detailed breakdown not just on the real susbsidy of parking at the college, but also how the school perhaps accidently encourages driving over other forms of travel.

For those of you who may not have time to read Zane’s full post at the moment, he’s given me permission to provide an excerpt below:

Accepting that a parking space costs $1122/year to provide, and that
Caltech only charges $480/year for a permit, what we have in effect is
a net $642/year or $53.50/month subsidy to drivers.  It is instructive
to compare this to the monthly subsidies offered on other methods of transit:

Mode Subsidy
Vanpool $50
Metrolink Train $50
Metro Pass (bus/light rail) $25
Bicycling $0
Walking $0

You’ll notice that driving is actually the most subsidized mode of
transportation, though vanpools come close to competing with driving on
an even playing field.  Metrolink doesn’t really count since it only
gets you as close at Union Station in downtown LA.  The odd thing is,
these subsidies are supposedly meant to incentivize the use of
alternative transportation options.  In reality, the biggest financial
incentive Caltech provides is for the thing that it doesn’t want you to
do: drive, and the smallest incentives ($0) are for walking and biking,
which require virtually no investment on the institute’s part, and
don’t generate congestion or pollution.  Additionally if the point of
the subsidy is to make one option more attractive than another, it
doesn’t make any sense to subsidize everything.  Doing so makes it
impossible economically to differentiate one option from the others. 
Furthermore, offering more money for the more expensive options hides
the real relative costs, which are then being borne by the subsidizing
party.

Image: Sea Digs/Flickr

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Ideas On How Metro and the Rams Can Expand Fan Transportation Choices

|
You may have heard that the National Football League’s Rams are back in Los Angeles. The football is no doubt exciting, but the team’s presence has also elevated Southern California conversations about parking, congestion, transit, and traffic. Now through 2018, the Rams play home games at the Coliseum in Exposition Park, a stone’s throw from the Metro […]

Editorial: Why Raise Metro Fares While Giving Away Metro Parking?

|
Metro is proposing to increase, or restructure, its $1.50 base transit fare to $1.75 later this year, with further increases planned in 2017 and 2020. Metro anticipates that this will increase its fare recovery – the percentage of operations costs that are paid for by fare revenues – from 25 percent to 33 percent. Metro foresees […]

Today in Two Steps Backwards: USC Discontinues Rideshare Subsidy Program for 3000+ Employees; Offers Parking Passes as Consolation

|
The letter sent to the more than three thousand faculty and staff that participated in USC’s Rideshare Subsidy Program this past June 16th started off happily enough. The USC Rideshare program is growing and continuing to evolve!  In 2015, we recorded our highest-ever Air Quality Management District (AQMD) survey result – an AVR (average vehicle […]