Skip to content

Posts from the "Transit Oriented Development" Category

9 Comments

TOD Turnaround: Bike Wood Coming to Hollywood and TOD Standards Coming to Everywhere


A 3D Rendering of a Future Bike Room in the Hollywood and Vine Development

When Legacy Partners’ Metro-Certified “Transit-Oriented Development” opened on Hollywood and Vine earlier this year, advocates weren’t able to contain their disappointment with several aspects of the project.  Among the complaints was that the development was too focused on providing space for cars and not access for cyclists and pedestrians.  However, that disappointment has led to opportunity.  As the months passed, activists were frustrated as developers, elected officials and even staff at the Metro Bicycle Roundtable Meetings were explaining why the Bike Room wouldn’t happen, not how to make it happen.

But things change and now The Hollywood Bike Hub appears to be on its way, and Metro is poised to make better bike facilities a part of its Transit Oriented Development standards.  Activists and Metro Board Members are lauding each other for making the Hollywood Bike Hub happen and Metro staff is talking about what they can do to make the Hollywood Bike Hub a major part of the Hollywood Community.

Not willing to take “no” for an answer, a coalition of bicycle, transit and community activists kept working and lobbying on behalf of a true Bike Hub at Hollywood and Vine.  Now their work has paid off, and a proposal to create such a space is on its way to the Metro Board of Directors.  At a meeting of the Metro Planning and Programming Sub Committee, Board Member Richard Katz added language to the proposal that would require the Metro staff to create formal T.O.D. standards which could have gigantic ramifications around the county as Transit Oriented Development is viewed as the key for Los Angeles real estate to rebound and for the county to grow.

The Hollywood Bike Hub proposed for Hollywood and Vine would offer secure parking, maintenance facilities similar to what exists at the co-ops, showers for commuters, information for tourists and new Metro users and perhaps even a bike-share and rental program.  Perhaps best of all,  Legacy Partners has given space to the HUB for a street-level, high visibility storefront property.  There won’t be a rental fee for Metro to maintain and staff the facilities. Read more…

Streetsblog.net 3 Comments

New Jersey Transit Village Program Continues to Grow

The holy grail for many urbanists contemplating long-term development and growth trends is the transit village. Adding growth adjacent to functional transit has the benefit of making it easier for the new population there to drive less and use transit for a multitude of trips. Likewise, transit villages can add to ridership on the transit lines, no small matter for operators seeking to maintain a consistent customer base.

Mobilizing the Region (MTR) reports New Jersey has added its 21st and 22nd transit villages in Somerville and Montclair. By designating the developments there as transit villages, Somerville and Montclair will get $100,000 planning and technical assistance grants and will move to the front of the line for other state grants the towns may seek.

The newly designated communities are each implementing transit-oriented development in their own way. Montclair is looking to develop around the Bay Street station by adding a commuter parking deck, seven residential developments with 163 units, a municipal fire station headquarters and a day care center. Somerville’s redevelopment efforts include plans to build a performing arts center, residential housing and parking decks near its station, and transform 40 acres of remediated landfill into recreation space with bike and foot trails and fields for residents.

The new grants also got the state’s chief executive on the record touting transit-oriented development. "The Transit Village program encourages local officials to surround nearby transit facilities with a vibrant mix of residential, retail and commercial uses," said New Jersey Governor Chris Christie in a statement. "This type of development spurs sustainable economic growth, maximizes the value of our transit investments and benefits the environment."

Read more...

13 Comments

Metro’s Hollywood & Vine TOD: a Fortress Surrounded By a Moat of Traffic and Malfunctioning Traffic Signals

On Monday, at Vine and Selma, a woman attempting to cross Vine on foot was killed after being hit by a delivery truck. The streets were immediately filled with LAPD vehicles and an investigation ensued. Although it was evident that statements were taken and that measurements and photos were taken, missing from the investigation was any evidence that the traffic signals were tested or surveyed. This is unfortunate because the signal at Vine and Selma is malfunctioning.

On the SW corner of Vine and Selma is the large Vine Village" id="xpwj" href="http://www.ansoniaproperties.com/sunsetandvine.htm">Sunset & Vine Village, a 300 unit residential/retail complex, filled with people who walk across the street to shop at Trader Joe's. At the NE corner of Selma and Ivar is Triangle Square, a 108 unit housing facility for elders. The people who cross the Vine at Selma use traffic control devices that are out of order. Malfunctioning equipment communicates to pedestrians that they are on their own and trains them to engage as opportunity presents itself.

It's been three months since Julia Siegler was killed as she attempted to cross Sunset Boulevard on foot. That incident prompted community challenges to the LADOT's signalization logic and to the LADOT's varied traffic signal strategies. At Vine and Selma, the demand actuated buttons work independently so that a ped call for a crossing on the north side will not yield a walk phase on the south side. Again, does it take a degree from MIT to cross the street? The LADOT has not responded.

Also, as a result of the tragedy on Sunset Boulevard, a request was made to the LAPD to include a survey of signal equipment as a routine element of a traffic collision investigation. Especially one resulting in a death. Apparently that request fell on deaf ears. The LAPD has not responded.

Read more...

36 Comments

Tragic Turn at the Hollywood and Vine T.O.D.

6_22_10_box1.jpgPhoto: Stephen Box
If Hollywood were to make a movie entitled "Hollywood & Vine - Transit Oriented Development" they'd have to hire professionals to manage the streets, control the traffic, move the trucks and make sure the entire environment was safe. There would be a 1st Assistant Director on set, legally responsible for the safety of all cast and crew, a commitment that would include a safety meeting each day. It's been this way for a long time, ever since the tragic incident on the set of "Twilight Zone" that took the lives of Vic Morrow and two child actors, Myca Dinh Le and Renee Shin-Yi Chen.

;

But "Hollywood & Vine - Transit Oriented Development" isn't a movie, it's simply real life. That means that there were no Teamsters on set, there were no SAG or DGA rules in place, there was no 1st AD on the streets watching out for the safety of the pedestrians crossing Vine on Monday afternoon when a truck driver traveling west on Selma passed an 18 Wheeler being unloaded and then turned north onto Vine Ave., striking and killing a woman as she attempted to cross the street.

Read more...

6 Comments

What Was Missing from Last Week’s T.O.D. Conference

(Earlier this week, Gloria Ohland reviewed what happend at last week's T.O.D. Conference hosted by the Urban Land Institute.  Today, Stephen Box takes a different look, and examines what was missing. - DN)

6_10_10_Box.jpgPhoto: Stephen Box
The Urban Land Institute's (ULI) Transit Oriented Development (TOD) Summit, held last Friday at the Hollywood & Highland's Renaissance Hotel, was as notable for what didn't happen as it was for what actually took place. As could be expected, hundreds of people representing local governmental authorities, agencies, and departments mixed it up with consultants of many flavors along with politicos of all stripes. This was, after all, a celebration of the future of TOD.

The ULI-TOD Summit also, inadvertantly, served as a metaphor for what's wrong with the TOD landscape in our community, in our city, and in this country; a focus on the big picture at the expense of the individual or personal experience. In other words, high-altitude, big-picture solutions that lack attention to details.

This Summit came complete with Senator Barbara Boxer's lunchtime announcement of Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood's endorsement of LA's 30/10 plan to leverage anticipated transit revenue in order to fast-track a dozen significant regional transit projects. Definitely huge! Along the way, the feds were represented, the state was represented, the county was represented and the City of LA's City Council President Eric Garcetti joined the feeding frenzy to add his blessings to the TOD lovefest. Attendees rubbed elbows with financiers, developers, consultants, innovators, real estate brokers, contractors and all of the many partners who work together to bring the magic of TOD to life, or at least to the ribbon cutting ceremony.

Read more...

2 Comments

Report from ULI Conference: The Future of Los Angeles Is Transit and TOD

6_6_10_w.jpgA view from the W Hotel. Photo: Gloria Ohland

Robust Attendance at ULI Event Indicates Developers, Investors and Feds On Board

The Urban Land Institute held a well-attended TOD Summit (as in transit-oriented development, or TOD) in Hollywood on Friday that signifies the quiet revolution going on in the world of transportation and development in Los Angeles. First, US Senator Barbara Boxer keynoted the lunch, announcing that the US DOT would admit both Phase 1 and 2 of the "subway to the sea" into the preliminary engineering process and conduct environmental review of both phases simultaneously - jumpstarting the subway project and greatly improving chances it will win federal New Starts funding.

Second, ULI released a positive analysis of the economic impacts of SB 375, the legislation requiring Californians to cutback greenhouse gas emissions to 1990 levels by 2020 through transportation and land use strategies, and to reduce emissions another 80 percent by 2050. This has become a politically volatile issue, and the oil companies are funding a campaign to get a measure to repeal AB 32, the landmark companion legislation that established the GHG reduction targets, on the ballot this fall.

Boxer also announced Congress would be including a strategy to fund LA's "30-10" plan to build all 12 rail and bus rapid transit projects funded by Measure R in 10 years in the upcoming reauthorization of the federal transportation bill. While there are a number of loan and bond programs that allow the federal government to provide funding for single transportation projects, there is no mechanism for funding an entire program of projects such as Mayor Villaraigosa has proposed with 30-10.

Both the 30-10 plan and SB 375 push the city and LA County toward a more compact and sustainable urban form focused around a rail system and non-motorized transportation. And the robust attendance at the conference indicated the degree to which developers and investors as well as the Obama Administration are interested in promoting transit, infill, mixed-use, TOD, and complete streets programs.

HUD's Shelley Poticha, senior advisor for HUD's new $500 million Sustainable Communities program and the morning keynote speaker, spoke about how HUD, the US DOT and the US EPA are all integrating their funding programs to promote sustainability and livability. Among the initiatives that HUD is considering, she said, is a new definition of housing affordability that will consider not just the cost of housing but also the cost of transportation, and that will reward those housing projects that reduce a household's transportation costs by providing good transit access and the option of walking and biking.

Throughout the day speakers talked about TOD projects in Los Angeles, about how to work with neighborhoods to build support for these projects, and how to find more funding for transit operations. There were afternoon tours of several projects, including the new Hollywood and Vine apartment, condo and W Hotel project, which features business conference rooms for residents as well as a hundred balconies and rooftop terraces with firepits, swimming pools and bars providing dramatic views of the Hollywood Hills, city and ocean. And there's a new Trader Joe's.

The panel of developers, mayors and others who spoke about the SB 375 analysis said that the Sustainable Community Strategy, or SCS, that is required under SB 375 will provide the certainty that both developers and investors need in order to build more mixed-use loft, live-work, and TOD projects near transit. The Southern California Association of Governments (SCAG) has begun working with its 189 member cities to develop an SCS by 2012.

Many of SCAG's member cities, including Fullerton and Ontario, have already begun dramatic upzoning around transit stations, and SCAG is tripling the funding in its Compass Blueprint Demonstration Program to provide for initiatives supporting mixed use, infill, TOD, walking and biking. Recent SCAG analyses for SB 375 show that cities across the region have been updating their general plans to reflect the planning priorities of SB 375.

For example, SCAG models show that more than half of all new development by 2020 will be built near transit stations across the region, and that the only new road capacity that is planned - with the exception of the 710 tunnel through South Pasadena and the proposed High Desert Corridor from SR 14 to the 1-15 - will be either HOV or HOT (high occupancy toll) lanes.

"SB 375 tells developers where they should be building - near transit stations, not in the greenfields," said Renata Simril, senior vice president of infill and mixed-use development for the national builder Forest City. "Time is money for developers and investors, and if we have the certainty that we are supposed to build near transit stations, then that is where we'll build."

No Comments

Tomorrow’s Big Urban Land Institute Conference Looks at 4 L.A. TOD’s

6_3_10_monrovia.jpgRendering of the Station Square Transit Village in Monrovia. Image via Visiting Gabriel Valley

The Urban Land Institute, a national organization that looks at Transit Oriented Development, has stepped up its working in Los Angeles recently.  In addition to releasing reports on the state of T.O.D. in the city, they've also sponsored workshops and discussions on some particular developments.  Streetsblog and the ULI don't always agree, (for example: they proposed more car parking as a cure for the problems with the Blue Line Slausson Station area), but there's no doubting the group's reach and expertise.

Tomorrow, they are sponsoring an all-day "summit" on the state of Transit Oriented Development in Los Angeles in the Renaissance Hollywood Hotel.  They're Technical Assistance Panels will be providing reviews and suggestions for four prominent T.O.D. projects in the county.  Joining Slausson Station will be the Green Line Vermont Station, Monrovia's Station Square Transit Village, and Jordan Downs.

They've also got a power-house lineup, headlined by Senator Barbara Boxer, and are promising some major announcements.  Regardless of your views on density, housing and urban growth; the reality is that the next phase of growth for Los Angeles is going to be around our transit nodes.  Whether we develop in a smart way, following the "transit oriented development" model or something worse, could determine what kind of Los Angeles we leave to our children.  If you're interested in attending, check out their website.  But don't worry, Streetsblog will have full coverage on Monday.

Streetsblog DC 1 Comment

Ford Foundation to Send $200M to Local Transit-Oriented Development

The Ford Foundation, created seven decades ago by a U.S. car industry scion, notably diverged from its past today by announcing a new, $200 million grant program aimed at promoting the local integration of transportation and land use planning and a movement beyond auto-based development.

Fruitvale_Village.jpgA "transit village" in the San Francisco area, cited by the Ford Foundation as an example of projects eligible for its new grants. (Photo: Bay Area MTC)

The foundation's president, Luis Ubiñas, revealed the move in a speech to local community leaders gathered at the White House to discuss the future of the nation's once auto-dominant cities.

Ubiñas cited several examples of existing transit and urban development projects that would be good candidates for the foundation's five-year grant program. The Bay Area's residential-commercial "transit villages," Detroit's public-private M1 light rail plan, and New Orleans' push to rebuild its Claiborne Avenue corridor topped the list.

“When we look at metro regions and see pockets of serious unemployment but also pockets of employment opportunity, and disjointed transit systems that fail to connect people to the services they need and the jobs they seek, it’s clear that a different approach is needed,” Pablo J. Farías, a vice president at the foundation, said in a statement on the grants.

The foundation was established in 1936 with an initial gift from Edsel Ford, son of the automaker Henry Ford, and managed by members of the Ford family for several decades after its founding.

4 Comments

NBC Opens Its Doors for “Community Meeting” on NoHo Development

5_12_10_wikimedia.jpgPhoto: Wikimedia

(editor's note: NBC Universal is holding a community meeting next Tuesday, May 18 at 4:00 P.M. at the Universal Studio's lot. You have to RSVP by this Friday, May 14 to get past security. Call 818-700-3583 to reserve a spot.  If you have trouble reserving a spot, please leave me a note in the comments section, as we're not certain if they're going to let in everyone interested in the project or just "supporters.")

For Los Angeles River and bicycle advocates interested in seeing the Los Angeles River Bike Path through North Hollywood to Canoga Park the planned development project at NBC Universal, the same project that would be built over the North Hollywood Red Line Station, has been a major obstacle.

When we last checked in on the project, which was almost two years ago, NBC was insisting on building a bike path, but detouring it away from the river for security reasons.  A Los Angeles Times article from two and a half years ago expresses concern that cyclists would throw scripts at important people's offices which would be a major distraction.  Really.

However, the same article also quotes both County Supervisor Zev Yaroslavsky and City Councilman Tom LaBonge supporting the idea of leaving the bike path directly along the river.  Plans for the path have consistently shown the path doing just that.

Read more...

3 Comments

TOD in LA Often Means “Transit Oriented Districts”

5_5_10_gloria_chart.jpg

(Editors note: Gloria Ohland was on the team that completed the LA TOD study for LA Metro and the City of LA, and was also involved in the U.S. DOT study that compared the GHG emissions of TOD to other development.)

Homeowner associations worried about keeping development out of their precious single-family neighborhoods really don't have to worry about transit-oriented development, or TOD. Yes, LA Metro does have some 26 TOD joint development projects underway to support the public investment in rail by adding density and riders to stations. But the dirty little secret about TOD in LA is that there's very little land near stations that is vacant or underutilized and available for development.

LA is built out, as a recent Caltrans-funded TOD study for LA Metro and the City of LA points out. Metro owns some land near the city's 71 stations, typically sites used to stage rail or station construction - and that is mostly where Metro's TOD projects are going up. But rail lines tend to serve mature neighborhoods. So making stations perform better - in terms of reducing transportation costs for households, vehicle miles traveled (VMT) and GHG emissions - isn't about actual development so much as it is about investing in better bike and pedestrian connections and in policies that promote a good mix of uses so people don't have to drive to every destination.

It's important to remember that the commute trip is just 18 percent of all trips made by households. So if at least some other trips - to daycare and school, shopping, the drug store, to go out to eat, etc. - can be made on foot or by bicycle or transit, then LA does indeed become a clean and green and more equitable city.

Transit-oriented LA would be more equitable because the American Public Transportation Association says owning, operating, insuring and parking a car in LA costs about $10,100 annually. And the study, the Los Angeles TOD Typology and Case Study Project, shows that while housing plus transportation costs (a household's two biggest investments) average 47 percent of area median income (AMI) nationally, housing plus transportation averages 54 percent of AMI in Los Angeles - but just 31 percent in transit-oriented neighborhoods like Koreatown and 26 percent in Boyle Heights.

Read more...