Applause for Bonin-Huizar L.A. Council Motion to Rein in LAPD Ped Stings

Brigham Yen/DTLA Rising
2013 LAPD pedestrian stings. Photos via Brigham Yen/DTLA Rising

Last Friday, May 1, Los Angeles City Council livability leaders introduced a motion [PDF] to get the city family to examine the effectiveness of LAPD’s ongoing pedestrian sting operations. We would like to think that SBLA’s recent article critiquing these stings paid off, but probably the excellent recent Los Angeles Times articles by Steve Lopez and Catherine Saillant got just a tad more exposure.

Motion 15-0546 was moved by Councilmember Mike Bonin, and seconded by Councilmember Jose Huizar. Huizar was pretty busy pressing for downtown livability last Friday, introducing five “DTLA Forward” proposals “to increase, promote and protect pedestrian access, improve traffic flow and improve neighborhood connectivity in Downtown Los Angeles.” Note that the LAPD crosswalk sting operations do extend beyond downtown into MacArthur Park and Koreatown.

SBLA does not often cover the fairly simple process of introducing motions, as there is a lot of follow-through needed before the City Council actually passes one… but we are pretty happy to have some activity on these wrongheaded stings that we have been writing critically about since 2008.

Bonin had this to say in describing the situation:

It defies common sense to ticket someone who is entering a crosswalk as the countdown begins when they still have time to cross the street safely without disrupting traffic. We need to be and we will be a Vision Zero city, and pedestrian safety is paramount. But if we are going to be doing ‘crosswalk stings,’ I want to be sure we are focusing on busting drivers who don’t yield to people in the crosswalk.

Excessive and expensive tickets disincentivize walking in Los Angeles. We want people to be safe, but we do not want ‘Do Not Walk’ to be the message we send Angelenos.

The motion critiques the outdated state law that serves as the basis for stings: 

…the law still references a traffic control signal that includes the words “WALK” or “WAIT” or “DON’T WALK” – illuminated devices, with few exceptions, that would now only be found in a museum.

If passed, the motion will direct the LAPD to report on the “public safety rationale” for enforcement, why some areas of the city receive much more enforcement than others, and request any evidence that pedestrian enforcement actually improves safety outcomes. In addition, LAPD and LADOT would have to report on how crosswalk stings align with LADOT’s Strategic Plan Vision Zero goal of eliminating traffic fatalities.

Though the city of L.A. can do a lot to foster a great, safe pedestrian environment, unfortunately it looks like some changes to state law may also need to happen. The deadline to introduce new bills has passed for 2015, but current bills could be still be modified. Maybe safety-minded Senator Carol Liu could call on the state to add a study of crosswalk law modernization to its review of bike helmet safety?

 

 

  • eirinnelson

    Rein, not reign.

  • Joe Linton

    ooops – thanks! fixed.

  • patrick

    I’ve said this before. Crossing the Street at 5th & Flower, with a walk signal, is the most dangerous thing I do on a regular basis.

  • Alex Brideau III

    Yeah. Those turn-only lanes seem to encourage driver speeding through the crosswalks. If there is an intersection downtown that needs some traffic calming, this one is at or near the top of the list.

  • The general understanding of the the countdown amongst law enforcement in the state is the that countdown is the equivalent of a yellow light, meaning you may enter the intersection on yellow/countdown, but you better have cleared it before red/red hand. LAPD is intentionally ignoring this common understanding in an effort to harass pedestrians. I doubt that LAPD really thinks that these stings increase safety, but they certainly serve to keep those people walking and people of color in their place.

  • Guest

    The city has “relaxed enforcement” (read: no enforcement) when it comes to illegal parking in Westwood and Silver Lake. Why can’t we have “relaxed enforcement” of this silly crosswalk law?

  • Guest

    Protest idea: Start crossing when green but cross a glacial pace to use the full time allotted from the countdown. Something like this maybe?

  • CityEye

    Huizar is deflecting from his money laundering campaign donations from his friends and didn’t Huizar get stopped for DUI? He’s the last person to be talking about safety

  • I think the amazing thing about that video is seeing cars yield to a pedestrian waiting. Where I live, I pretty much have to jump in front of them, and get honked at, in order to cross. The only advantage of using the crosswalk is that when someone inevitably does hit me, they’ll be at fault.

  • ubrayj02

    He can deflect some more if it is going to lead to a more human scaled city. It’s not like the anti-pedestrian and anti-bike riding politicians in city hall are any cleaner in their fundraising and level of being sold out.

  • Here’s an idea: How about a sting to ticket the drivers that almost run us over in the crosswalks!!

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Interview with Luke Klipp of Jaydancing

|
For as long as I can remember, Streetsblog Los Angeles has been lamenting the L.A. Police Department’s targeted ticketing of pedestrians. LAPD “jaywalking” enforcement occurs mostly in downtown Los Angeles, but also outside various central Los Angeles Metro rail stations. I am excited that Los Angeles City Councilmembers Mike Bonin and Jose Huizar recently introduced […]

Today’s Headlines

|
Happy Bike Month (Santa Monica Next) L.A. City Councilmembers Question DTLA Pedestrian Stings (LAT) Councilmember Huizar Introduces Four Motions For DTLA Livability (DT News) West Hollywood Residential Street Blames Waze For Traffic (WeHoVille) Bike the Vote Endorses Carolyn Ramsay In L.A. CD4 Run-Off Election OC’s 405 Freeway Expansion May Cause Long Beach Bottleneck (KPCC) Hermosa/Redondo […]

Today’s Headlines

|
Jaydancing L.A. Gets Down in DTLA Intersections (DTLA Rising) Today 2 p.m. Bonin-Huizar “Jaywalking” Stings Motion At Transpo Committee [PDF] East L.A. Residents Concerned About Health Impacts of 710 North (KPCC) New Lancet Report Makes Climate Change Health Impact Connections (Pasadena Star News) DTLA Streetcar Will Cost $328M, Hitting Issues (Downtown News) Bernard Parks Doing […]

Transportation Committee Questions LAPD’s 8,000+ Annual Ped Tickets

|
This afternoon the Los Angeles City Council Transportation Committee discussed a motion questioning the effectiveness of LAPD’s “jaywalking” enforcement. The pedestrian enforcement motion, 15-0546, was authored by City Councilmember Mike Bonin, who chairs the committee. LAPD reported that there was no way to provide the analysis requested in the motion, but did provide some pedestrian enforcement […]

Today’s Headlines

|
Ridley Thomas: Unused South L.A. Rails Will Become Bike/Ped Friendly Greenway (MRT Blog) Op/Ed: Bonin and Garcetti Are Really Excited About Rail Plans for LAX (Daily News) LAPD Handing Out $250 Jay Walking Tickets in DTLA… (DTLA News) …Downtown News Calls Ped. Sting a “Crackdown” Curbed Goes for “Total Bullshit” Everyone Is Stunned by the […]