Steinberg Kills Bill That Sought to Delay Cap-and-Trade on Fuels

Mobile billboard against the "hidden gas tax." Photo via CA Drivers Alliance Twitter
Mobile billboard against the “hidden gas tax.” Photo via CA Drivers Alliance Twitter

The misinformation campaigns trumpeting an imminent “hidden gas tax” in California lost a battle with the defeat of Assemblymember Henry Perea’s bill, A.B. 69, which was designed to delay application of cap-and-trade to the fuels industry for three years.

Fuel companies have already begun participating in the state’s cap-and-trade auctions, buying pollution credits that they can use to help them meet the greenhouse gas emission cap set by the state. Emission caps will not apply to the fuel industry until this coming January, but they have had years to prepare for it.

Senate President Pro Tem Darryl Steinberg sent a letter to Perea [PDF] explaining his decision not to let A.B. 69 go forward. The bill may not have had much of a chance of passing anyway, but this settles the question without the Senate or Assembly having to take it up in the final few days of the legislative session.

A.B. 69 was originally a bill about water quality, and had been considered and passed in the Assembly as such, when at the last minute Perea completely rewrote it, in what’s called a “gut and amend.” At that point, it was in the Senate, where it would have had to pass out of several committees and then pass with at least a two-thirds vote on the Senate floor before the Assembly could take it up.

Steinberg killed it in the Rules Committee. In his letter to Perea, he wrote that “bringing non-stationary fuels under the cap is not an unforeseen issue that demands legislation which sidesteps the democratic process.” And “a measure of this importance should not be considered in the final weeks of a two-year session.”

Senator Steinberg’s letter discussed the consequences California is already facing from climate change and addressed the “economics of doing nothing”:

Jobs: “Stalling California’s clean transportation program would result in thousands of lost jobs from reduction in clean transportation investment. Using the federal-state formula, transportation infrastructure investment in this year’s budget alone will result in more than 8,000 jobs.”

Health costs: “A May 2014 study from the American Lung Association finds that California’s Low Carbon Fuel Standard and bringing fuels under the cap will save Californians over $10 billion in health and societal economic costs by 2020.”

Fuel costs: “The average Californian will pay 20 percent less in fuel bills by 2020 as a result of AB 32 thanks to increased diversity and competition among fuel suppliers.”

Assemblymember Perea had focused his arguments for the bill on the effects of gas price increases on low-income people without access to transit, but failed to explain how a delay would help them. Other groups have decried cap and trade as a  “hidden gas tax” that will shock consumers, and even the LA Times focused on the increase in prices as if it were a guarantee, rather than a cost that is likely to be passed on to consumers by oil companies.  But the fuel industry has been anticipating this for years, and since companies are already participating in the cap-and-trade auctions, their costs are going up now—not in January.

The Legislative Analyst’s Office estimated that the price of gas might go up between 13 and 20 cents a gallon, but points out that the amount is less than the fluctuations in gas prices Californians have experienced in the last year [PDF].

  • Alex Brideau III

    And so the “California Drivers Alliance” rails against the supposed “hidden gas tax” using a gas-guzzling mobile billboard. Classic.

  • James Fujita

    If Assemblyman Perea is concerned about poor people without access to transit, he should work harder to make sure they have access to it.

  • Jeff Parkerpetersen

    The cost of EVERYTHING is going to go up. Who doesn’t see that? The cost of an EGG is going to DOUBLE!!

  • Anandakos

    Time to defenestrate Assemblyman Perea. Kick him out of the caucus and strip him of the chairmanship which he so egregiously abused. He’s a DINO. Out!

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

The Hidden Gas Tax That Doesn’t Exist

|
You may have seen the ads on Facebook, or on one of the roving billboards being pulled by a gasoline-powered truck. They warned darkly of a coming “hidden tax” on fuel that was so hidden nobody in the media was talking about it. You may have wondered what it meant, even as the ads urged […]

Sen. Steinberg Proposes Carbon Tax on Gas Instead of Cap-and-Trade

|
CA Senator Darrell Steinberg proposed a change yesterday to California’s nascent cap-and-trade program that would replace next year’s cap on fuel emissions with a per-gallon carbon tax. Steinberg called it a “broader, more stable, and more flexible” way to reduce emissions from fuels than cap-and-trade. His proposal would apply the revenue raised from the tax […]

Bill Aims to Delay Bringing Fuels Under CA Cap-and-Trade System

|
In a last-minute maneuver before the California Legislature’s summer recess, Assemblymember Henry Perea (D-Fresno) amended a bill to delay the application of California’s cap-and-trade system to fuels until 2018. Co-authors of the bill, A.B. 69, include Assemblymembers Cheryl Brown (D-Fontana), Tom Daly (D-Anaheim), Isadore Hall (D-Rancho Dominguez), Roger Hernandez (D-West Covina), Freddie Rodriguez (D-Chino), and […]

CA Sen. Steinberg Proposes New Spending Plan for Cap-and-Trade Revenue

|
Senate President Pro Tempore Darrell Steinberg (D-Sacramento) announced a proposed plan to create a permanent spending strategy for cap-and-trade revenue [PDF] that prioritizes investments in affordable transit-oriented housing, transit expansion, and CA high-speed rail. Unlike the Governor’s plan for this year’s budget, Senate Bill 1156 also proposes investments in “complete streets” and transit operations. Calling the […]