Active Transportation Advocates Secure Fair Competition for State Funding

Safe Routes To School projects get a level playing field after yesterday’s Metro board vote on an amended Active Transportation proposal. Photo: Safe Routes To School National Partnership

At yesterday’s Metro Board meeting, bike and walk activists won a small victory to ensure a fair process for projects seeking state funding.

As SBLA reported earlier, federal changes resulted in Metro no longer receiving federal bike and pedestrian funding that Metro had granted to cities. Metro is looking to withdraw from about $90 million in already-approved bicycle and pedestrian projects scheduled for funding through 2019.

Metro had approved project funding via its Call for Projects (Metro Call), but is instead requiring cities to seek California Active Transportation Program (ATP) funding to replace lost Metro funding. Cities will be competing in a statewide ATP process; applications are due May 21st, 2014.

Eyeing the Metro budgetary bottom line, Metro staff had proposed giving Metro’s selected projects an extra 10 points in their rankings. This would have tipped the scales in favor of state funding replacing former Metro funding, but would have created an unfair process. Projects that Metro approved in the past, whether still viable or not, would be at an advantage over all other bike and pedestrian projects.

Additionally, ATP combines several pots of money, so, under the Metro proposal, there would be entire classes of projects that would be at a competitive disadvantage. The Metro Call has not included Safe Routes to School (SRTS) projects and programs; these were funded directly by the state in the past. So, under the Metro staff proposal, all L.A. County Safe Routes To School applications would be at a competitive disadvantage.

The Los Angeles County Bicycle Coalition and the Safe Routes To School National Partnership were vocal in drawing attention to the flaws in Metro staff’s proposal. The organizations submitted this joint comment letter, and testified before Metro committees last week and before the full board yesterday.

Fairness concerns found sympathetic ears among Metro board members. Duarte City Councilmember John Fasana cited the need for clear transparent criteria before advancing some projects over others. Los Angeles City Councilmember Mike Bonin also stressed the need for projects to compete on their current transportation merit. Bonin worked with Fasana to amend Metro’s proposal to direct Metro staff to pass along all L.A. County ATP project applications on an equal footing. The amended level-playing-field proposal was approved by the full Metro board yesterday.

Though this is a small victory for active transportation in Los Angeles, a lot of uncertainties remain.

Los Angeles County has not competed well in the past for statewide funding for bike and pedestrian projects. Time will tell how L.A. does with the new ATP funding process. Metro’s projects still face a shortfall. Without an official thumb on the scale, these projects will compete with others and may or may not receive funding to offset Metro’s shortfall.

Overall, walking and bicycling account for a growing share of state and local trips, but still compete for minuscule pots of funding. Locally, Metro moves mountains to fund multi-billion dollar rail budgets, but declines to be much more than a very limited pass-through for active transportation. 

Other ATP news this week: The Los Angeles City Department of Transportation (LADOT) presented its ATP project list to the city’s Transportation Committee last wednesday.

LADOT is applying for funding for 35 projects. These pedestrian and bike projects vary from Living Streets in Boyle Heights, to the Los Angeles River Greenway in Studio City. Seventeen of the city’s applications are for formerly Metro Call funded projects. Six of L.A.’s applications are for Safe Routes to School projects, for schools including Hollywood High School, and Elementary Schools: Selma Avenue, Breed Street, Sheridan Street, Menlo Avenue, West Vernon Avenue, 28th Street, Quincy Jones, Dolores Huerta, and Castellar. Each SRTS project can include multiple schools.

An additional twelve LADOT applications are for other pedestrian and bike projects, neither Metro- nor SRTS-related. See the full project list in the LADOT staff report

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Federal Changes Causing Metro to Withdraw Previously Approved Funding for Bike and Ped Projects

|
At last week’s board meeting, Metro weighed the future of its commitment to funding active transportation: walking and bicycling. Changes in federal government funding are leading Metro to withdraw from its past bike and ped programs. Right now, 49 projects, totaling over $90 million, are on Metro’s list for “transition.” Metro had approved funding for these, […]

SCAG Staff Release ATP Bike/Ped Project Funding Recommendations

|
The first year of the state’s new Active Transportation Funding (ATP) program is drawing to a close. ATP is the main source of funding for walking and bicycling projects and programs in L.A. County. In the past, L.A. County bike and ped projects were primarily funded by Metro’s Call for Projects. Changes at the federal level […]

Metro July Meeting Re-Cap: Subway, SRTP, Active Transpo, and More

|
Metro’s July Board of Directors meeting took place yesterday. As usual, it was four-plus hours long, with plenty of implications for the future of livability and transportation for the region. SBLA re-caps the meeting below. Mayor Garcetti Assumes Board Chair Yesterday’s meeting was Mayor Eric Garcetti’s first as the new chair of Metro’s Board of […]

Metro Committee OKs Dismal Walk/Bike Plan Now, Funding Report Later

|
More than fifty people showed up at this week’s Metro Planning and Programming Committee to urge the Metro board to support active transportation. Metro’s proposed $88.2 billion, ten-year Short Range Transportation Plan (SRTP) includes only $500 million for active transportation funding. Though walking and bicycling make up nearly 20 percent of L.A. County trips, Metro allocates […]

CTC Staff Releases California Active Transportation Program List

|
The California Transportation Commission has released a list of recommended projects that could get funding from the state’s Active Transportation Program. The ATP is a new statewide grant program that funds bicycle and pedestrian improvements throughout California. The list is expected to be approved by the full CTC at its August 20 meeting. Under the ATP, the […]

Five Reasons Why People Who Bike Should Vote Yes On Measure M

|
Streetsblog L.A. endorsed Measure M, Metro’s proposed sales tax to fund transportation infrastructure and programs throughout L.A. County. Voters will decide the fate of Measure M next Tuesday. If you get around on bike, here are five reasons you will want to vote yes on Measure M. 1. A Local Funding Stream For Bicycling: Two Percent […]