L.A. City Council Considers Multiple Sidewalk Repair Motions

Broken sidewalk on Alameda Street in downtown Los Angeles. Photo: Roger Rudick
Broken sidewalk on Alameda Street in downtown Los Angeles. Photo: Roger Rudick

Today at 2 pm, the Los Angeles City Council’s Budget and Finance Committee agenda includes two council motions regarding repairing city sidewalks.  One motion (Council file 13-0600-s109) proposes a city “limited sidewalk repair plan.” Another (Council file 13-0941) proposes eliminating permitting fees for sidewalk construction and repair.

According to Councilmember Buscaino’s press release, the limited sidewalk repair plan will dedicate $10 million to sidewalk repair. The plan is a collaborative product of the city’s Public Works Department (Bureau of Street Services, Bureau of Engineering, and Bureau of Contract Administration) and City Administrative Officer. All construction would be performed by private contractors, with city oversight. All $10 million goes to sidewalk work, split into three equal $3.33 million components:

  • One third responding to lawsuits: high pedestrian use locations where poor conditions have already resulted in lawsuits being filed
  • One third for “iconic streets”: promoting economic development in retail areas with heavy pedestrian traffic
  • One third for a “50/50 program”: the city and property owner split sidewalk repair costs. This third would be divided equally among the 15 council districts. 

Additionally, last week, another sidewalk repair council motion was introduced. Councilmember Blumenfield’s motion (Council file 14-0163)  proposes just the 50/50 sidewalk repair program. According to Blumenfield’s office, the city’s prior 50/50 sidewalk repair program ran from 2004-05 through 2008-09, with  a budget of $7-10 million annually. Over five years, the program resulted in about 2500 completed sidewalk repair projects. 

Each of these motions have some potential to help improve sidewalk conditions, though each motion needs to work its way through the city’s legislative and administrative processes. There’s no shortage of council proposals that have languished due to a lack of political will to see them through to on-the-ground improvements.

Why the flurry of motions and press releases related to sidewalk repair? There’s some heat on the issue from media attention, from increasing visibility of pedestrian advocacy organizations including Los Angeles Walks, and especially from the ongoing cost of settling lawsuits. These pressures have sparked some attention, and, apparently, now some competition among councilmembers as to who can get credit for being L.A.’s sidewalk repair champion.

Representatives from L.A. Walks suggested that, while these proposals could result in some welcome small gains for pedestrians, overall they represents a piecemeal approach. These pedestrian advocates aren’t opposing the council initiatives, but would prefer a more comprehensive approach, with sufficient ongoing funding to repair and maintain sidewalks.

Is a $10 million sidewalk repair program this year enough to show that the city is taking its estimated $1.5 billion sidewalk repair backlog seriously? Are the current proposals the first steps in the right direction? How do we get to a more comprehensive initiative? What sidewalks would you like to see repaired first? Your comments below.

  • Matt

    $10M is not enough to even start to make a dent, although it is better than $0, which is a disgrace. The City needs to get closer to $50M a year to have any meaningful progress. With Measure R’s city match, I am still stunned they can’t come up with something somewhat meaningful here.

  • Urbanexplorer

    Any discussion about sidewalk repair needs to take into account the difficult but necessary decision to replace street trees. Most often, it is the roots of these trees that are heaving the sidewalks up. In our neighborhood, large patches of sidewalk were replaced about 10 years ago. Nothing was done about the giant silk oak street trees. Consequence? The sidewalks are heaved up again.

  • ChrisLoos

    Great, $10 million. Only 150 short years until we tackle that entire $1.5 billion backlog.

  • TimB

    Shoupista-style parking reform with funds dedicated to sidewalk repair would easily be able to produce the necessary funds.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

L.A. City Council Eliminates Sidewalk Repair Permit Fees

|
Los Angeles took a very small step forward on the issue of sidewalk repair. Hopefully that metaphorical step forward doesn’t too closely resemble the very real steps L.A.’s pedestrians are taking on the city’s treacherous and lawsuit-ridden buckling sidewalks. Estimates place L.A.’s broken sidewalks at more than 4,600 miles. At its Tuesday meeting, the Los […]

An Underwhelming Sidewalk Repair Day at L.A. City Hall

|
A little less conversation, a little more action please All this aggravation ain’t satisfactioning me A little more bite and a little less bark – song performed by Elvis Presley (words by Billy Strange, Mac Davis) Elvis did not necessarily have Los Angeles sidewalks in mind when he asked for less conversation and more action, […]

Eyes on the Street: Some L.A. City Sidewalk Repairs On the Way

|
The city of Los Angeles has a $27 million set aside for sidewalk repair during the current fiscal year, which ends June 30. This is only the proverbial drop-in-the-bucket for L.A.’s estimated $1.5 billion in overall unmet sidewalk repair needs. Based on liability and property concerns, the city is only spending its $27 million repairing […]

L.A. City’s Ten Million Dollar Sidewalk Repair Program Turns Inward

|
At Monday’s Los Angeles City Council Budget and Finance Committee, the city’s proposed $10 million sidewalk repair program took a turn inward. After closed session deliberations over sidewalk lawsuit liability, Committee Chair Paul Krekorian relayed the committee’s action to focus on “damaged sidewalks abutting city facilities.” According to city estimates, L.A. has a $1.5 billion […]