Fixing a roundabout that isn’t, Just a Block from the Beach

The difference between a roundabout and a traffic circle? One misplaced stop sign.

When is a roundabout not a roundabout?

Evidently, when it’s located roundabout the beach in Santa Monica.

It’s not that the city by the sea hasn’t made great strides in recent years, particularly in justifying its designation as a Bicycle Friendly Community. The new Green Street on Ocean Park Blvd. shows Santa Monica’s commitment to re-imagining streets to accommodate all road users, as well as the environment.

On the other hand, some of the legacy streets could stand to see some improvement. Like tiny Bay Street between Neilson Way and the beach, for instance.

One of the problems for those of us who ride our bikes to the beach from points further inland is how to access the popular Santa Monica and Venice sections of the beachfront Marvin Braude bike path (pdf) that runs along the coast from Pacific Palisades to Palos Verdes.

The bluffs that protect the city from the sea also limit direct access to the coast, as does the dangerously high-speed traffic that careens along PCH all day and night throughout the week.

For some, the answer is the walkway that runs under the coast highway at West Channel Drive, allowing riders to walk their bikes down a flight of stairs and underneath the speeding traffic. Assuming they don’t mind traversing a dark and secluded walkway, completely hidden from public view.

While Gary Kavanagh is on a short hiatus, Ted Rogers and Juan Matute will cover the Santa Monica beat for Streetsblog. This column is supported by Bike Center and the Library Alehouse

Others prefer to ride across the crowded bridge over PCH to the Santa Monica Pier, then work their way down various stairs or ramps to access the beach.

And still others enter the pathway at its southern terminus at the Venice Pier, or the many parking lots between the two.

My preference, however, is to circle the traffic island on Bay Street, zip down the hill, around a second island and onto the bike path.

It’s actually very easy to find, despite being hidden from heavy traffic on nearby Nielson Way.

Riders headed south through SaMo can follow the bike path on Ocean Ave to the intersection with Pico Blvd, where Ocean Ave forks off to the right, while Nielson Way continues south (directions are relative, since Santa Monica’s curvature around the bay doesn’t allow it to adhere to a standard north/south grid).

Sharrows in both directions suggest Santa Monica wants to encourage bike riders to use Bay to ride to and from the beach.

Following Ocean Way to the right leads to Bay Street one block later, where a simple right turn leads down to the beach. Sharrows installed within the past few years make it clear that the city wants to encourage cyclists to use the street.

The problem comes with the poorly designed intersection one block later at Ocean Way, barely visible in the satellite photo.

Or rather, the city’s lack of faith in their own infrastructure.

Roundabouts are designed to channel traffic in a single direction, allowing drivers to go straight, make a U-turn or turn onto a cross street in either direction without encountering cross traffic, eliminating the need for traffic signals and reducing the risk of collisions.

However, what you’ll encounter on Bay Street is actually a traffic circle, rather than a roundabout; traffic circles use stop signs or other traffic signals to control the flow of traffic, while roundabouts are unsignalized, using the design itself to control traffic.

The Bay Street traffic circle has a stop sign in each direction on Bay, with no traffic signs controlling vehicles entering from Ocean Way. Which means that cyclists riding along the sharrows are forced to stop where it makes no sense, or break the law by riding through the stop sign.

In practice, it only serves to confuse just about everyone.

Tourists from other countries, where roundabouts are more common, aren’t looking for a stop sign there, and may drive right through it; I’ve nearly been rear-ended more than once when I’ve stopped on my bike and the driver behind me didn’t.

It’s also where a passenger in a car entering from Ocean Way got out and threatened to beat me up because I dared to tell the confused driver of the car he was in that she didn’t have to stop for the stop sign that wasn’t there.

A misplaced sign below the crest of a steep hill makes it difficult for bikes to stop.

However, the problem is compounded going uphill, where stopping safely is difficult, if not just this side of impossible.

By placing the stop sign just before the crest of the steep hill, riders are forced to choose between running the stop sign, or risking a dangerous fall or loss of control in an attempt to obey the law. Let alone the difficulty of resuming riding on an uphill slope if they somehow manage to.

It’s the only stop sign in Southern California I run on a regular basis, because it’s significantly safer than the alternative.

In fact, I made two attempts to stop there on a recent ride.

The first time, I wasn’t able to clip out of my pedals in time, wobbling dangerously and barely avoiding a fall. In the second, I succeeded in stopping — barely — but was forced to duck walk the remaining several feet to the crest of the hill before I could get back on my pedals again.

Of course, there’s an incredibly simple solution, whether you’re riding to or from the beach on Bay.

Just remove the stop signs.

Turn the traffic circle into a genuine roundabout, where every vehicle entering — bikes included — must yield to any other vehicle in the circle.

It will eliminate — okay, reduce — the confusion, given the difficulty many drivers in this country seem to have in comprehending the relative simplicity of roundabouts. It will improve safety. And encourage more bicyclists to use Bay Street as a safe and relatively easy way to access and leave the beach.

Or if Santa Monica really feels a need for traffic signs, they can replace them with yields in each direction.

Which would be sort of like a European-style roundabout, but with American subtitles.

Video: Biking the Bay Street Roundabout

 

  • Anonymous

    Pasadena also has a few “roundabouts with stop signs” (ex. Glenarm and Los Robles) that seem to be the worst of both worlds. The stops signs interrupt the flow of traffic jsut like a normal four way stop, and the added roundabout just makes the intersection larger, harder to see who is doing what, and harder to decide who has right of way.

  • Kptkarl

    Those stop signs are fairly new, within the past year I believe. I wonder what prompted them to install them after years without.

  • Erik Griswold

    Shouldn’t they be Yield signs?

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Long Beach, Santa Monica, If YouDonate to Streetsblog in May…You Can Win More Than Just a New Bike

|
The Southern California Streets Initiative, the local non-profit that staffs and edits Streetsblog Los Angeles, has voted to support local journalism outside of the city limits to Long Beach and Santa Monica. Thanks to local support from Santa Monica Bike Center and Long Beach Community Foundation, we’ve been able to do this without reaching into our regular […]

The Week in Livable Streets Events

|
There’s a good amount of wonk stuff on the calendar this weekend, but it closes with a Bike Party in Santa Monica.  Of course, I guess every week closes with a Bike Party.  Pay special attention to the events on Wednesday. Monday – The LADOT takes their designs for roundabouts on 4th Street to the […]

Three Years Later, Is Santa Monica’s Bike Action Plan Working?

|
In November 2011, the Santa Monica City Council unanimously — and enthusiastically — adopted the Bike Action Plan (BAP), an ambitious 300-page document that seeks to transform the bayside city into one of the most bike-friendly cities in the country. The BAP, the culmination of years of work by City Planning staff, local bike advocates, […]

Santa Monica Debuts Two New Bikeway Designs

|
Lately it seems like every week in Santa Monica there is something new happening that makes it easier and more pleasant to get around without a car. New sharrows there, a new bike lane here, bike racks popping up at shops all over town. New pedestrian oriented mixed use developments are going in several at […]

Pushing Planning Boundries in Santa Monica with James Rojas

|
(editor’s note: This story is written by James Rojas, who’s sustainable transportation models have been featured here at least three times in the past.  His most recent model, one of a Santa Monica geared towards cyclists and pedestrians, can be viewed at the 18th Street Art Gallery in Santa Monica until March 27 as part […]