When a Door Closes, a Window Always Opens…Because Someone Will Saw Through the Fence

The unofficial entrance to the South L.A. Wetlands Park. That's Maya Angelou High School in the background. (photo: sahra)

The South Los Angeles Wetlands Park located at 54th and Avalon is having a rough go of it these days.

Earlier this year, officials had to drain it in order to replace the leaking ceramic basin with plastic liners. It remained dry as a bone until the recent drizzling rains. But those have left it looking more like a fenced-in mud pit than a park. It appears to have even depressed garbage-eating seagulls and other fowl. None were to be found when I stopped by yesterday.

It wasn’t particularly beautiful to begin with — to passersby, it resembled a lot of dirt sparsely sprinkled with plants. The water often resembled more of a big puddle or muddy pond than an oasis, and there was no real place for kids to play or people to sit.

Still, it was a major improvement over the 9 acres of trash-collecting blight that it had been before. The abandoned former bus and rail yard now cleans the runoff waters that flow through it with native plants, offering area schoolchildren firsthand lessons about how ecosystems work. And, the looping trails provide a peaceful spot for joggers, elder residents who enjoy a stroll at sunset, and mothers out for a walk with young children.

Even knowing that neighbors had been slow to embrace it, I was genuinely surprised at how empty it was yesterday afternoon. The high school across the street had just let out and the students that I had seen cutting through the park when it first opened were nowhere to be found.

Taking a loop through the park, I realized that all the exits were locked with rusty padlocked chains. The only open entrance was the one to the parking lot, off Avalon. There would be no passing through the park — you only entered it if you specifically wanted to spend some time there.

Students make use of the hole in the fence so they can cut through the park on their way to and from school (photo: sahra)

Apparently that hadn’t sat well with someone. Two bars from the fence along 55th St. had been sawed or broken off, and another had been bent so that people could get through. A well-worn trail leading to the makeshift exit indicated that it had been there for a while.

I watched two students emerge from the park through the fence and asked if they knew who had done the deed.

No, they said, but they were glad someone had. Now they could get to school easier and even fit their bikes through the fence if they needed to. They didn’t understand why the gates had been shut so soon after the park had been opened.

They wanted to be able to walk through the park. Having to walk around it made it more of an obstacle than an asset to them.

And it seems silly.

Part of ingraining the importance of park space on people’s consciousness involves making these spaces accessible to them and essential to their daily lives. Even if the students don’t regularly hang out in the park, having a clean and safe place to cross through that they know is there for them is important. It is a refuge from the busy streets, may pique their curiosity in the natural sciences as the park matures and becomes a more lush ecosystem, and it becomes part of what they value and remember about their community. They will want park space near their homes when they begin their own families.

Locking out the park-poor community that the park was supposedly designed to serve doesn’t make a lot of sense, in other words.

No entrance for you, young lady. (photo: sahra)

A call to the parks department yielded little in the way of information. The first person I spoke with was surprised to hear about the hole in the fence. He’d have to send another email about the park again, he said. Thinking that meant he was in regular contact with park staff, I asked if he could give me the information of his contact.

There was a pause.

Let me see who that would be, he says. He came back with the general number for the Pacific Regional Headquarters Office.

The next person I spoke with tried to send me to an engineer.

No, I really just wanted to know about the gates, I said.

Oh, she said, saying she would send someone to make sure that the front gate was open. And that the mistake was probably due to budget cuts being what they were.

No, I clarified. It is all the other gates — the park is inaccessible to the youth that live in the area and want to pass through it.

Not, incidentally, unlike Augustus Hawkins Natural Park, located on Slauson and Compton. Also a wetlands, it is completely gated off on three sides instead of being open and inviting to the public. It is a lovely park, no doubt, but it feels inaccessible. The vegetation has grown so much along the fences, you can’t even see in much of the park from the street, making it feel even more separate from the community. Kids that live directly across from it on 57th St. have to make their way a third of a mile down towards Slauson — a heavily trafficked major thoroughfare — instead of being able to use one of the locked gates they can see from their front steps.

To be fair, the maintenance supervisor was not able to speak to me today as he was out of the office, so there may be some rational reason behind the locking of gates that I am unaware of. But it seems so counter-productive to the purpose of putting parks in communities. And because the only entrances are ones attached to the parking lots, it puts cyclists and pedestrians — especially small children — at greater risk. Even if there are costs to keeping the gates open, it would seem that the improvements to the health of park-goers gained by making the site more easily and safely accessible — the stated rationale for building the park in the first place — would outweigh them.

 

 

  • Anonymous

    Sounds like “everyone will drive to the park to experience nature” thinking… like the rail trails in Massachusetts that have big parking lots all along them and don’t really go anywhere, because, you know, everyone is going to drive there to ride their bikes.

    The other one that always gets me is parks that have paths that curve around pointlessly or lack obvious connections in the paths – again, the thinking is that you just came here for nature, not that you might be passing through and want to go somewhere. Maybe someone needs to tell landscape architects about desire lines ;)

  • LA

    Yes, should be open with multiple entrances that make for most accessibility and best usability. FYI: Agustus Hawkins Park had pretty bad crime and drug dealing problems way back when until they locked all but one gate. If you saw it before you would know why all but one entrance are locked now.

    Since it is new the issue at this park is probably just a lazy park worker who doesn’t want to deal with multiple locks and chains.

  • LA

     The random curving path and missed connections kills me too! So contrived. Can we think about function people?!?! I think it is the “Olmsted esthetic” lingering around. 

  • Ubrayj02

    No joke, I started riding with a pair od bolt cutters when I used the Arroyo Seco bike path to get to and from work. I was late to work too many times to count because a drizzle on Friday night meant the gates were still locked on Monday morning.

  • Anonymous

    @91bd029c91bd1708d55ef318a914789f:disqus I used to live in Boston (hence the tag) and after the Big Dig, they replaced the old highway with parks, one of which was a rectangle and had curving paths, roughly making three legs out of the “X” that would have connected all four corners. People walked on the missing leg so much that it started to kill the grass.
    The response was to put up a fence to keep people from walking there. Classic.

  • sahra

    To me, locking the gates is a sign of an unwillingness of the powers that be to invest in actually making a community a better place. It isn’t a question of lazy park workers (and not at AH Park–I’ve met the people working there and as far as I know, they have no control over the gates). Officials make all this fanfare about how important parks are to the community so they can say they care about parks and the health of the community, but little investment is made into the other aspects of what makes a community healthy. It is a shame.

  • Great article calling out the multi-billion dollar boondoggle known as state employment.  Calling the park and expecting to speak to anyone who (1) Gives a damn; or (2) Knows anything whatsoever about the locked gates in question is a fool’s errand, especially in California.  State employees don’t know, and what’s more, they don’t *want* to know.  They’re just in the office to watch the clock, collect a paycheck and then go home. Don’t hold your breath waiting for anyone from the park to call you back. 
     
     
     
     

  • Dave

    Sahra,

    Thanks for writing about some of the parks in South LA. I suspect it is a combination of things based on my proximity and knowledge of things in South LA. Crime may be part of the issue like someone commented. Also, back in 2010 when the City of Los Angeles laid off employees the library and parks were the first departments to get cut. They laid off scores of park employees and library employees. (Measure L brought back library services though). Because parks lost employees and money maybe these parks were closed down. However, this is not an excuse for closing these parks. I contacted the parks dept. before, but they never responded. It is sad and frustating to read that you called 2-4 people to get an answer from the the parks dept.

    I tried going to Agustus Hawkins Park and could not enter. Sad. We hardly have any green space in South LA. I am going to contact Jan Perry’s office and see what they say…

  • Joe B

    What’s the purpose of fencing off the park in the first place? Do they want to lock it up at night or something? (Does that really deter crime, or merely make a safe/isolated space for criminals who know how to climb/cut fences?) Why not just leave the park open on all sides, so that people can easily visit?

  • This seems to be a common problem.  Even for a park like Barnsdall Art Park, I normally see that the pedestrian gate is closed, so visitors on foot have to walk all the way around to the car entrance, and then double back through the parking lot to get to the pedestrian staircase.  It’s only a minor inconvenience, but still insulting to the people who actually live in the community.

  • Nathanael

    The one piece of good news in this depressing article is that the Department of DIY is alive and well in LA.

    Here in the conformist Northeast, I doubt anyone would have gone to the trouble of dismantling the fence as a public service.  The spirit of anarchic community service lives in LA.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG