At CNU, Representative of Texas Legislature says “No Road Pays for Itself”

Over the past two days at the Congress for the New Urbanism Project for Transportation Reform conference, attendees have called for transportation reform at local, regional, and
national levels. In a panel debate about the future of transportation funding and the
role of regional planning through MPOs, several speakers argued that
the foundation of transportation and development funding had to be
systematically overhauled.

Mike Krusee, chairman of the Texas House of Representatives Transportation Committee, said that financial problems
were more significant than environmental, though they should be tied
together in the same discussion. "The reason there’s not a new
transportation bill is because there is no money. We’ve hit the wall of
unsustainability on how we finance the transportation system," he said.

Krusee asserted it was urgent and necessary to understand
the nature of this broken financial apparatus and to develop solutions
to fix it. In Texas, he
said that, on average, it cost the state 20-30 cents per person per
mile to build and maintain a road to the suburbs, yet drivers only pay
on average 2-3 cents per mile through the gas tax, vehicles fees, etc.
"What we found was that no road that we built in Texas paid for
itself," said Krusee. "None."

The expense to build roads and
utilities further and further from the urban cores was not only driving
costs to unsustainable levels, it created an imbalance in who paid for
growth. Over the past 50 years, Krusee argued, the federal government was
using tax money that came by and large from cities to subsidize roads
to areas without access otherwise. "City dwellers have subsidized the
land purchases and the development costs out in the suburbs," said
Krusee. What’s more, the gas tax, which city dwellers pay when driving
on city roads, but which goes to freeways largely outside of urban
cores, is "a huge transfer of wealth from the cities to the suburbs to
build these rings."

Krusee said
building the Interstate system was initially a good thing,
because if facilitated interstate commerce and increased the
productivity of cities.  Now however, because of congestion caused by
ever longer commute patterns, system productivity is in peril. "What’s
happened is the federal government has basically reneged on the deal.
By subsidizing highways out to the suburbs, it’s no longer efficient
for truck traffic, for goods and services and people to move between
cities in the United States because those roads have been hijacked by
all the commuters."

Gateway Planning Group’s Scott Polikov lamented not
only the current funding situation — "bankruptcy" — but the reform
proposals made by Transportation for America (T4A) and other
advocates for only tinkering
with the traditional 80 percent highway, 20 percent transit levels, not fundamentally changing
the federal funding mechanism to support cites.

"If
the blueprint plans, the regional plans, are not specifically tied to
the funding, then as far as I’m concerned, there’s no point in doing
the planning because what is ends up doing is creating expectations
that are unrealistic," said Polikov.  " If all we focus on is TOD and
Regional planning, but we don’t restructure the entire policy basis for
the highway funding… then I fear that we’re really just still in the
margins and we’ve reinvented the same system and we’ve declared victory
when in fact it’s not going to be victory."

Reforming the Transportation Bible

Another topic that has long been on CNU’s radar for reform is
AASHTO’s "Green Book," the bible for traffic engineers. As we reported, CNU Chief John Norquist has been working
with the Institute for Transportation Engineers (ITE) to add urban
street concerns to the comprehensive roadway guidelines. Rick Hall, of Hall Planning
and Engineering
, in a plenary session yesterday elaborated on changes that would benefit pedestrians.

"There’s not a single mention of pedestrians in the
entire first
chapter of the AASHTO’s green book," said Hall. "It’s all about cars."
He argued that AASHTO’s street classifications (arterials,
collectors, locals) do not account for walkability inputs that make
urban streets comfortable and livable. 

In
Hall’s opinion, MPOs and traffic engineers should start by indentifying
cities that work for pedestrians, then use computer modeling and
simulations to simulate urban forms in those cities, not just the
travel and movement of motor vehicles.  For Hall, the most important
walkability design parameters are, in order of importance:

  • Small block size
  • Buildings fronting the street
  • Mixed-land uses
  • Lower traffic speeds
  • On-street parking (pedestrian buffer)
  • Interconnected streets
  • Narrow streets
  • Quality Sidewalks
  • Lower traffic volumes
  • Street Trees

Hall
called for a change to AASHTO’s guidelines, including the creation of a
new classification he called "compact urban," where speed limits would
be lower and a number of pedestrian factors would be considered in
conjunction to road characteristics.  In compact urban areas, he said,
road design should not allow for speeds greater than 25 mph, versus
AASHTO’s current urban low-speed of 45 mph. MPOs
could determine that they want to alter development patterns to add
compact urban areas to suburbs and re-design streets accordingly.

CNU President Norquist told the audience he anticipated positive additions to the Green Book by 2010.

Throughout the
day Friday, CNU participants have broken out into working groups to
discuss the various proposals put forth in the conference and bring
them together into the working document, Sustainable Transportation
Network Principles [PDF], which the organization will take to policy makers in Washington D.C.

  • Paul Crabtree

    Great reports. How about the promised green streets tour report?

  • It’s bittersweet to see Krusee making such sense on highways, since he was directly responsible for destroying Austin’s chances at workable rail transit for at least a generation. Polikov’s not much better on that score.

  • I guess that some day, this sort of information about highways and freeways will reach the editorial page and letters section of every major newspaper the next time the “transit doesn’t make a profit” line comes up.

    What would it take to do a similar analysis of roads in L.A. or the state of California as the one they did in Texas?

  • after visiting los angeles a couple years ago, and walking through the maze of and ‘cant get there from here’ gangways that is to be found in downtown los angeles – this is wonderful news – hall is right on about walkability, small block size, etc.

    one thing i hope they dont forget in the ‘Compact Urban’ plan is — BICYCLES — there really is no oil crisis — if people would just remember how great it is to ride bikes.

    as a 10 year+ cyclist in toronto (yes – we bike through 80 degrees weather in the summer, and through the snow in winter…) — including bicycle lanes — so people can usefully get to work/bank/shopping — would lessen dependance on oil —

    i had a bmw 320i — sold it — got a bike ten years ago… best thing i ever did. never need to run like a hamster on a treadmill in a gym — body feels great… zero car repair bills. zero gas & oil… no more oil crisis.

    everything in toronto is located within 20-30 minutes bicycling distance — so there’s nowhere you cant go.. toronto island is the largest car-free community in north america — people say it is so nice… so peaceful… until they notice that there are no cars… but there’s a bicycle parked in front of every house… carts to get groceries… and its fun! so much more enjoyable than a car (well, yes, winters are a bear, but that’s only two months out of 12) — i’m sure you wouldn’t have to deal with that in L.A. tho…

    anyhoo — all the best to you out on the west coast from toronto island. :-D

    jp

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

STREETSBLOG USA

Just How Bad Is the Final House Transportation Bill?

|
Nobody was expecting the GOP-controlled House of Representatives to put together a transportation bill that did much for streets and transit in American cities. And they were right — there’s nothing to get excited about in the bill. But neither is it the total disaster for walking, biking, and transit it could have been. So how does the House bill […]

President Obama’s Proposed FY15-16 Budget: $330M for L.A. Subways

|
U.S. President Barack Obama released his administration’s proposed FY 2015-16 budget which includes $330 million in New Starts funding planned for subways in Los Angeles: $115 million for the Regional Connector $115 million for Phase I of the Westside Subway Extension (Purple Line from Western to La Cienega) $100 million for Phase II of the […]

San Diego County Sets Aside $2.5 BILLION for Bicycles and Pedestrians

|
Earlier this week, the San Diego Union-Tribune reported that the San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) allocated $2.58 billion of their thirty year plan for bicycling and pedestrian infrastructure improvements.  If that seems like a big number, it is.  While Los Angeles has been celebrating it’s Bike Plan, and the Measure R set-aside that’s going […]

CNU Transportation Project Raises Bar on Planning for Livable Cities

|
Photo: npGreenway The Congress for the New Urbanism’s Project for Transportation Reform summit in Portland, Oregon, has brought together transportation engineers, city planners, and transportation reform advocates to share best practice policies for reforming transportation metrics, funding mechanisms, and regional practices that isolate transportation planning from land-use and growth targets.  The highlight of the first […]

CNU Summit to Focus on Reforming Transportation, Planning Principles

|
The Congress for the New Urbanism will meet in Portland, Oregon, in early November for the annual Project for Transportation Reform, a summit to further define and clarify emerging urban transportation policies that embrace entire networks, rather than interdependent transportation segments, and that seek to balance modal transportation splits and reduce overall vehicular miles traveled […]