Think Tank Responds to Report on Hidden Costs of Fossil Fuels: Yawn

The National Academy of Science’s new report
on the hidden health costs of U.S. reliance on fossil fuels has
generated high-profile media coverage around the country, most of it focusing on the $62 billion annual estimate for coal rather than the $56 billion projection for vehicles.

CarExhaust.jpg(Photo: SILive.com)

But Greenwire’s write-up is particularly interesting, if only for its responses from the National Mining Association and the Competitive Enterprise Institute, a conservative and climate-denying D.C. think tank that has taken $2 million from Exxon Mobil this decade. From the Greenwire piece (sub.req’d.):

"Energy production from fossil fuels causes air
pollution, which damages people’s health and welfare. That was big news
— in the 1970s," Marlo Lewis, a senior fellow at the Competitive
Enterprise Institute, wrote in an e-mail. "Did we really need a
346-page study with more than 50 expert contributors to tell us that?" …

"That aside, without energy, we’d all freeze in the dark," Lewis added.
"The net cost of not having energy vastly outweighs the supposed
‘hidden’ costs."

Interestingly,
Lewis’ quip about "the net cost of not having energy" was similar in
substance from the that of the Mining Association, which asserted that
"the health and welfare benefits" of burning coal for electricity
"clearly outweigh the cost."

  • Some people smoke to keep warm in the winter. Obviously, the health and welfare benefits of cigarettes outweighs the cost

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

New Study Shows $56 Billion in Hidden Health Damage from Autos

|
Transportation’s effects on public health are rarely discussed by policy-makers, but they remain very real — and the National Research Council (NRC) put a number on them today, reporting that cars and trucks have about $56 billion in "hidden" health costs that are not reflected in the price of oil or electricity. (Photo: MetroDCLiving.com) In […]
STREETSBLOG USA

Nigeria Strikes for Cheap Fuel

|
For the last two days, Nigeria has been on fire with national protests against the government’s move to drop the fuel subsidy that has kept gasoline cheap for years. All of a sudden, on January 1, Nigerians awoke to find that gas prices had gone from 65 naira (40 cents) to at least 141 naira […]
STREETSBLOG USA

Grover Norquist Buckles to Pressure From Koch-Backed Group on Carbon Tax

|
Some readers took issue with yesterday’s post that characterized a carbon tax as a terrific but politically unlikely proposal, after the Obama administration shot down the idea last week. Putting a price on carbon emissions is, after all, generating renewed interest from across the ideological spectrum. Notably, the libertarian American Enterprise Institute is co-sponsoring a forum on […]

APHA Tallies ‘Hidden Health Costs’ of Transportation Status Quo

|
The nation’s transportation planning process fails to account for more than $200 billion per year in "hidden health costs" imposed by traffic and air pollution, according to a new report from the American Public Health Association (APHA) that maps the nexus between infrastructure and health care. Traffic brings with it billions of dollars in "hidden […]