‘Clunkers’ Consequences: GM Sales Down, Ford Gas-Guzzlers Up

When Congress tripled the size of the "cash for clunkers" program in July, both Congress and the White House
billed the $3 billion program as a boon for struggling domestic
automakers. But when those Detroit car companies released sales figures
today, the numbers didn’t quite match up to the hype.

082409_clunker1__1251140010_9010.jpg(Photo: AFP/Getty)

General
Motors and Chrysler, which required a combined $65 billion in
government loans before declaring bankruptcy, reported August
year-to-year sales declines of 20 percent and 15 percent, respectively.

Detroit media reports focused
on GM’s 30 percent sales increase between July and August 2009, but the
company’s car sales were down 1 percent even after being "bolstered" by
the taxpayer-funded "clunkers" rebates.

Ford, the lone U.S.
automaker that did not require a government rescue, reported a 17
percent year-to-year sales increase in August. As the New York Times
reported, the company was pleased by one sales jump in particular:

At Ford, sales of the F-series, a large pickup truck popular among
building contractors, rose for the first time since October 2006, a
positive sign for the automotive market and the broader economy, the
company said. Ford sold 13 percent more of the F-series and 57 percent
more of a smaller pickup, the Ranger.

“It may be a glimmer of
hope,” Ken Czubay, Ford’s vice president of marketing, sales and
service in the United States, said on a conference call.

The F-150, the most well-known of the F-series trucks, gets an average of 16 miles per gallon (mpg) of gas. The Ranger gets between 16 mpg and 23 mpg, depending on the engine and transmission. "Glimmer of hope," indeed.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

A Last Word on Cash for Clunkers…We Promise

|
One thing the government’s CARS program — a.k.a. "cash for clunkers" — has clearly stimulated is commentary. For a policy involving a shade under $3 billion in federal spending, it has enjoyed no shortage of media coverage. (Photo: Newsday) In part this is because the program looks like a big success, and certainly congressional leaders […]

Could Electric-Car Tax Credits Become the Next “Cash for Clunkers”?

|
The White House’s commitment to electrified cars, fulfilling an Obama campaign promise to put 1 million plug-in hybrids into service by 2015, is bound to have serious ramifications for the nation’s already-crumbling system of paying for transportation. (Photo: MPR) But could the administration continue to leave the gas tax untouched while relying on taxpayer-subsidized rebates […]
STREETSBLOG USA

GAO: Economic Recovery Benefits of ‘Cash for Clunkers’ Are ‘Uncertain’

|
"Cash for clunkers," the White House’s much-touted program encouraging trade-ins for more fuel-efficient autos, had an "uncertain" impact on economic recovery, according to a new audit from the independent Government Accountability Office (GAO) — largely because it remains unclear how many of the car sales it spurred would have occurred without taxpayer subsidies. Were "clunker" […]
STREETSBLOG USA

Brookings: “Cash for Clunkers” Wasn’t Worth It

|
Turns out paying people to buy cars isn’t a great policy for the economy or the environment. That’s the determination of a pair of Brookings Institution researchers who evaluated the effectiveness of the 2009 Cash for Clunkers program. The $2.85 billion program, part of President Obama’s economic stimulus package, produced only 2,050 “job-years,” according to researchers […]